What Are The 5 Cs Of Copyediting

Gary Smailes | 2 November 2025

The Five Cs in Context

Ask five editors what copyediting does, and you will hear the same spine. Five steady checks that keep prose friendly to readers. Clarity. Correctness. Consistency. Concision. Coherence, and completeness. Think of them as lenses. Each pass sharpens a different part of the picture.

Clarity asks a simple question. Does the reader know who did what, where, and why. Strip away fog. Replace vague pronouns. Unsnarl long sentences.

• Muddy: When Jake met Tom, he told him his plan.
• Clear: When Jake met Tom, Jake shared his plan.
• Too packed: Owing to budget limits, staffing reductions, and shifting priorities, the department decided to postpone the rollout until the fall term.
• Cleaner: The department postponed the rollout until fall. Budget limits, fewer staff, and new priorities drove the decision.

Correctness keeps the mechanics sound while preserving voice. Grammar, punctuation, spelling, and usage. The goal is credibility without flattening rhythm.

• Error: The list of risks are long.
• Fix: The list of risks is long.
• Error: Its a good idea.
• Fix: It’s a good idea.
• Dialogue punctuation, quotation marks, subject–verb agreement, pronoun case. All tuned to a style guide, not whim.

Consistency spares readers from stumbles. Pick one form, then stick with it. Capitalization, hyphenation, italics, list style, even the spelling of made-up terms.

• Drift: email in chapter one, e-mail in chapter four.
• Decision: email throughout.
• Drift: OK on page 3, okay on page 90.
• Decision: OK throughout.
• Drift: Adviser in the foreword, advisor in the bio.
• Decision: Adviser throughout.

Concision trims without thinning meaning. Remove throat clearing and filler. Prefer strong verbs over noun-heavy phrasing.

• Wordy: In order to make a decision, the team held a meeting.
• Tight: The team decided in a meeting.
• Wordy: It is important to note that results vary.
• Tight: Results vary.
• Wordy: Each and every student must complete the form.
• Tight: Each student must complete the form.

Coherence and completeness check the map and the parts list. Ideas should flow in a logical order. All promised elements should exist, be labeled, and match references.

• Flow: Cause before effect. Claim, then evidence. Scene setup, then action.
• Completeness: If the text says “see Figure 2.3,” there needs to be a Figure 2.3, with the right caption and number. If a chapter promises six steps, the chapter should present six steps.

Where this work sits in the process matters. Copyediting follows developmental or line editing, and arrives before proofreading. The big moves and style choices should be stable. Sentence-level quality and accuracy take center stage. Think of this as the phase where every comma earns its keep, and every sentence says exactly what you mean.

Two tools anchor decisions. A style guide and a dictionary. Agree on them before the edit starts. For trade books, The Chicago Manual of Style pairs well with Merriam-Webster for US work. For UK work, many houses favor New Oxford Style Manual with Oxford dictionaries. These references settle debates fast.

• US example: toward, not towards. Theater, not theatre, unless the proper name uses theatre.
• UK example: towards, not toward. Theatre, not theater, except in proper names.
• Hyphenation example: decision making as a noun is open per Merriam-Webster. As a modifier, hyphenate, decision-making process.
• Numbers example: Spell out one through nine. Use numerals for 10 and up. Keep the rule on your style sheet, then apply it everywhere.

That brings us to the living style sheet. This is the book’s memory. It records choices so nothing drifts, even across months or across a series. Start it on day one. Update as you go. Share it with every stage, including typesetting and proofreading.

What to include:

• Spelling choices. adviser, not advisor. email, not e-mail. lowercased internet, web, and website.
• Hyphenation. start-up as a noun, start up as a verb. high school open as a noun, hyphenated only as a modifier if your house requires it.
• Capitalization. Government is lowercase, unless part of a proper name. Board of Trustees capitalized when referring to the formal entity, lowercase when generic.
• Numerals. Spell out one to nine. Numerals for 10 and above. Percent symbol with numerals, 8 percent, unless house style uses %.
• Dates and time. 5 June 2025 for UK. June 5, 2025 for US. 9 a.m., not 9am.
• Terms of art. Define the author’s preferred technical terms. Note trademarks and generic forms. Velcro is a trademark. Use hook-and-loop fastener when generic language is needed.
• Series notes. Character names, ages, eye color, hometowns. Map names. Calendar rules for the world.

A quick starter exercise:

1. Read the first chapter. Jot five choices you notice. Pick forms for each and log them.
2. Search the manuscript for each item. Standardize while tracking changes.
3. Hand the style sheet to your editor before work begins. Invite additions during the edit.

One more habit pays off. When a ruling shifts midstream, record the change with a date. Then revisit earlier chapters. A single decision on hyphenation or capitalization often touches dozens of lines. The style sheet keeps you honest.

The Five Cs are not a slogan. They are a checklist that keeps readers oriented and engaged. Use them to focus attention. Use references to settle questions. Use a style sheet to hold the line. Do this, and your prose reads like you on a clear day, with no speed bumps.

Clarity

Clarity earns trust. Readers should never pause to decode a sentence. Meaning first, music second. Match phrasing to the audience and tone.

Start with three quick questions.

• Who does what.
• When and where.
• Why does this matter to the reader.

If a sentence fails any of those, revise.

Tactics for clearer sentences

Replace vague pronouns. Repeat the noun or recast the line.

• Muddy: When Maya met Alex, she praised the outline.
• Clear: When Maya met Alex, Maya praised the outline.
• Clearer still: Maya met Alex and praised the outline.

Untangle long or nested sentences. One idea per sentence works wonders.

• Packed: Due to budget constraints announced last winter, which have worsened across multiple departments, the committee decided to postpone the program until the next fiscal year in order to reassess priorities and staffing needs.
• Clean: The committee postponed the program until next fiscal year. Budget constraints announced last winter worsened across departments. The group will reassess priorities and staffing needs.

Prefer concrete nouns and strong verbs.

• Flabby: The team made an improvement.
• Strong: The team improved.
• Flabby: We performed an analysis of sales.
• Strong: We analyzed sales.

Define or trim jargon. If a term serves a precise need, include a plain-language gloss on first use.

• Jargon-heavy: We plan to synergize cross-functional initiatives.
• Plain: We plan to coordinate work across teams.

When a term shows up often, consider a short glossary. Readers love quick answers.

Narrative clarity

Point of view guides every beat. Hold one lens per scene unless the project calls for a clear shift.

• Head hop: Jonah doubted the plan. Across the room, Mara felt safe for the first time all day.
• Single lens: Jonah doubted the plan. Across the room, Mara smiled, shoulders loose.

Anchor time and place fast. One clean cue sets the stage.

• Weak: We left and walked for a while.
• Strong: Monday, before dawn, outside the bakery.

Sequence action in the order a camera would catch it. Cause before effect.

• Off: She slammed the door, then grabbed the keys from the table outside.
• On: She grabbed the keys from the table, stepped outside, and slammed the door.

Watch dialogue beats. Pair a line with a clear speaker cue when two names share a scene.

• Muddy:
  “I never agreed to that.”
  “You did last week.”
• Clear:
  “I never agreed,” Lena said.
  “You did last week,” Omar said.

Nonfiction clarity

Heading hierarchy signals logic. Each level should nest cleanly under the one above. Apply one style for each level and keep the order steady across the book.

Lists need parallel structure. Match form and tense.

• Mixed: Goals for Q3: 1) grow revenue, 2) fixing support response time, 3) customer retention.
• Parallel: Goals for Q3: 1) Grow revenue, 2) Fix support response time, 3) Increase customer retention.

Open each section with a purpose line. Set expectations in one sentence.

• Example: This section explains how to set up the tool and avoid common errors.

Charts, tables, and examples should answer a clear question. Label each element in a way a skimming reader will grasp in seconds.

Actionable checks

• Read aloud or use text-to-speech. Muddled syntax and awkward rhythm jump out when a voice reads the line back.
• Query the author when meaning feels uncertain. Never “guess edit.”
• Break one long sentence into two when more than one idea rides along.
• Add brief transitions where paragraphs jump in logic. Try short bridges such as So, Next, By contrast, For example, As a result.
• Hunt vague pronouns. Search for this, these, those, he, she, they. Confirm every reference.
• Highlight jargon in one color and plain words in another. Decide where a definition helps and where a swap serves the reader better.
• Do a “verbs pass.” Replace weak verb plus noun combinations with a single strong verb. Decide becomes decide, make a plan becomes plan, provide assistance becomes help.

A quick exercise

Pick a page from your draft.

1. Circle every sentence over 25 words. Split at natural seams.
2. Underline pronouns. Write the noun above each one.
3. Box every heading and list. Check hierarchy and parallel form.
4. Read the page aloud. Mark every place your voice stumbles. Fix those lines first.

Clarity takes nerve. Choose the simple word. Choose the direct line. Readers reward clean thinking.

Correctness

Clarity wins the room. Correctness keeps the room. Readers forgive bold style. Errors stop them cold. Your aim is clean, accurate prose that still sounds like the author.

Mechanics worth your full attention

Punctuation shapes meaning. Get it right, then leave it alone.

• Commas. Use them for lists, for direct address, and to set off nonessential phrases. Cut the ones that create comma splices.

  • Splice: The data looked strong, we launched on Tuesday.
  • Fixed: The data looked strong. We launched on Tuesday.
• Semicolon use. A semicolon links two complete thoughts, or it separates complex list items. If doubt creeps in, use a period.

• Dialogue punctuation. In US style, commas and periods sit inside closing quotation marks.

  • “I know,” she said. “Leave now.”

  In UK style, punctuation placement follows logic and often sits outside.

• Quotation marks. Use double for speech in US books, single for quotes within quotes.

  • “He said, ‘Go home.’” Keep nesting tidy.

• Possessives. For singular names that end in s, many houses prefer s-apostrophe-s.

  • James’s bike. The Joneses’ house.

• Subject verb agreement. Match number, not the nearest noun.

  • The bouquet of roses is lovely. Not are.

• Pronoun case. Use me, him, her after prepositions or in compound objects.

  • Between you and me. Not I.

• Logical comparisons. Make the comparison equal on both sides.

  • She likes jazz more than he does. Or she likes jazz more than him, depending on meaning. If readers might stumble, rewrite.

• Modifiers. Park them next to what they modify.

  • Dangling: Walking to the store, the wind slapped my face. The wind did not walk.
  • Fixed: As I walked to the store, the wind slapped my face.

Do a slow pass for each item. Short checklists prevent sloppy misses.

Spelling and usage

Pick a system and stick to it. US or UK. Do not mix color and colour in one chapter. Lock choices for toward or towards, traveled or travelled, program or programme. Record them in your style sheet.

Spot the usual traps.

• Homophones. Its vs it’s, your vs you’re, peak vs pique, rein vs reign.
• Variants. Email vs e-mail, web page vs webpage. Pick one.
• Idioms. Toe the line, not tow the line. Free rein, not free reign.
• Word pairs. Compliment vs complement, discrete vs discreet.

If a regional term suits the voice, keep it. If a malaprop creeps in, fix it and leave a note.

Numbers and units

Numbers ask for rules. Make them plain and apply them everywhere.

• General prose. Spell out one through nine. Use numerals for 10 and up. Keep one style within a context.

• Start of sentence. Spell out, or rewrite to avoid a clunky opener.

  • Awkward: 37 people showed up.
  • Smooth: Thirty-seven people showed up. Or use a lead-in line.
• Ranges. Use an en dash without spaces, as in 3–5 years, or write 3 to 5 years. Do not mix.
• Dates. Pick 5 July 2025 or July 5, 2025. Not both.
• Time. Use 3 p.m., not 3pm, unless house style says otherwise.
• Units. Use a space between number and unit, 5 kg, 20 mm. Percent style, 50 percent or 50%, should match the book.
• Hyphens. Use them for compound adjectives before a noun, long-term plan, but drop them after the noun, the plan is long term.

Check math in tables and examples. Confirm totals, rates, and averages. Make sure figures in text match what sits in charts and captions.

Light fact-checking

Copyeditors do not replace researchers. You do catch shaky claims before they go to print.

• Dates and days. If a scene falls on Friday, July 5, 2024, confirm the weekday. Timelines slip.
• Chronology. A pregnancy does not last twelve months. A twelve-hour flight does not land three hours after takeoff without time zones in play. Scan for clock logic.
• Names and brands. iPhone, YouTube, LinkedIn, Wi‑Fi. Use house style for the hyphen in Wi‑Fi and the capital F in JavaScript.
• Places. Spell cities and regions per the chosen dictionary, or per official sources.
• Quotes and citations. Verify wording, titles, and page numbers. If a pull quote edits out words, mark the cut with an ellipsis. Confirm attribution.
• Procedures. Court filings, lab steps, medical protocols. Look for red flags and query. Do not rewrite expertise you do not hold.

When a claim feels off, leave a clear query. Respect the author, protect the reader.

Actionable checks

• Lock your dictionary and style guide before you start. Chicago with Merriam‑Webster for US projects. New Oxford Style Manual with Oxford Dictionary for UK work. Note every ruling in the style sheet.
• Run targeted searches. there, their, they’re. your, you’re. Double spaces. Spaced em dashes. Straight quotes mixed with curly quotes. Hyphen variants, email and e‑mail.
• Sweep for dialogue. Tag missing closing quotes, comma splices inside speech, and inconsistent speaker tags.
• Verify every quoted passage against the source. Check references, endnotes, figure captions, and cross references for accuracy and order.
• Do a numbers pass. Check units, ranges, and percent style. Match every figure in text to its table or chart.
• Track exceptions. If house style bends for voice, record where and why.

A quick tune-up

Take one page.

1. Mark every sentence boundary. Fix run-ons and fragments.
2. Circle every quote mark. Check placement and pairs.
3. Underline each number. Apply your number rules. Check math.
4. Highlight homophones. Confirm each one.
5. Read the page aloud. If a line sounds off, test a simpler fix.

Correctness is discipline plus care. Err on the side of plain sense. Keep the voice, lose the mistakes. Readers notice the difference.

Consistency

Consistency is kindness to the reader. Stable rules keep eyes on meaning, not on bumps in the prose. Make a decision once, record the decision, repeat without wobble.

Style uniformity

Pick a style for common choices and stick with it across chapters.

• Capitalization. Governor Brooks when a name follows, the governor when a title stands alone. Internet vs internet, decide once. Marketing Team or marketing team. Record house preferences for headings, too.
• Hyphenation. Hyphenate compound modifiers before a noun. A well-known author. The author is well known. Close up permanent compounds after frequent use if a dictionary supports the choice. Decision today means no second-guessing tomorrow.
• Italics. Foreign words, ship names, TV series, internal thoughts. Choose rules and apply them evenly. If inner monologue uses italics in Chapter 1, use the same treatment in Chapter 20.
• Serial comma. Apples, pears, and plums, or apples, pears and plums. Pick one system.
• List punctuation. Periods on full-sentence bullets. No periods on fragment bullets. Keep alignment and capitalization parallel within each list.
• Headline case vs sentence case. A Guide to Better Meetings, or A guide to better meetings. Match cover, front matter, and chapter heads.

Quick test. Open three random chapters. Scan for email vs e-mail, OK vs Okay, adviser vs advisor. Any mixed forms need a ruling on the style sheet.

Content continuity

Readers track names, places, timelines, and invented terms without conscious effort when details hold steady. Break the chain and trust starts to fray.

• Names and spellings. Alison in Chapter 2 becomes Alyson in Chapter 9 only if a reason exists. Nicknames, initials, particles in last names, all need recording. McDonald, MacDonald, de Gaulle, DeLuca. Do not guess.
• Ages and life details. A brother born in 1998 remains 25 during a 2023 story. A dog named Noodle does not morph into Noodles three scenes later. If a character loses a ring in Scene 5, the ring should not sparkle in Scene 7.
• Places. South Side or Southside. Downtown or the downtown district. Street abbreviations in text, Third Street vs Third St. Pick forms and apply them.
• Invented terms. Magic systems, software modules, guild names. Shardstone or Shard Stone. Version 2.0 or v2.0. Record plural forms as well.
• Timeline sequencing. Chapter dates, seasons, weekday references. Friday at the end of Chapter 3 means Saturday opens Chapter 4 unless travel or time zones intervene. Draw a quick calendar in the style sheet.
• POV labels. For multi-POV work, decide on chapter headers or on-scene labels. Maya, Cole, Lydia. Use the same order and spelling each time.

A small series bible helps here. One document tracks backstory, vocabulary, ages, timeline, and maps. Share with everyone on the project.

Formatting choices readers never notice

Presentation rules fade when applied with care. Uneven styling, by contrast, shouts.

• Chapter openers. CHAPTER THREE, Chapter 3, or 3. Set a pattern for number style, small caps, and spacing under the header. Keep epigraph placement and spacing uniform.
• Scene breaks. Centered asterisk, three spaced asterisks, or a blank line. In ebooks, prefer a visible glyph. Record the choice.
• Epigraphs. Italic or roman. Quote marks or none. Attribution on a new line or run in. Source style, with or without a comma before a name. Lock the template.
• Tables and figures. Table 2.1 or Table 2-1. Figure 3A or Figure 3-A. Title case or sentence case on captions. Standardize labels and numbering logic.
• Callouts. See Chapter 7 or see chapter 7. Section 3.2 or §3.2. Again, one rule.

Tools to hold the line

A living style sheet sits at the center. Include:

• Dictionaries in play and the chosen style guide.
• Spelling and hyphenation rulings, including gray areas.
• Capitalization rules and exceptions.
• Number style, time and date format, percent style.
• Common names with approved spellings, including nicknames.
• Formatting patterns for heads, subheads, lists, captions, and callouts.

Share the style sheet with authors, designers, and proofreaders. Keep revisions dated. Carry the same file into typesetting and proof.

Use software support where helpful.

• PerfectIt flags inconsistent hyphenation, capitalization drift, and acronym handling. Run a pass before and after big edits.
• Word wildcard searches catch patterns. Try space-hyphen-space, double spaces, straight quotes, and e mail. Search for two or more spaces before punctuation. Search for three variants at once with pipes inside parentheses, for example, (advisor|adviser).
• For series work, maintain a timeline spreadsheet or a one-page bible with dates, chapter numbers, and summary beats. One glance tells you whether Tuesday follows Monday.

Actionable checks

• Perform a dedicated consistency pass after the main edit. Focus on rulings, not on new rewrites.
• Revisit earlier chapters when a decision changes midstream. Update the style sheet, then run searches to bring older pages into line.
• Skim heads in the Navigation pane. Head levels, capitalization, and numbering should match the plan.
• Sample three lists across the book. Check list punctuation and alignment. Fix drift.
• Run a hyphenation audit. well-being vs wellbeing, long-term vs long term, decision-making vs decision making. Mark the preferred form. Apply everywhere.
• Do a name sweep. Search for every major character and place. Look for stray spellings or honorific drift, Mr. Patel vs Dr. Patel.

A five-minute drill

Pick one chapter.

1. Write three rulings on the style sheet, for example, serial comma, okay vs OK, toward vs towards.
2. Run searches for the chosen items. Fix outliers.
3. Scan the first and last page of the chapter for names, dates, and place forms. Align to the style sheet.
4. Check the chapter header and any epigraph against the template.
5. Leave a note for any ambiguous case, then move on.

Consistency never steals the spotlight. Consistency lets readers forget about rules and focus on meaning. Keep choices steady and the prose will feel stronger, page after page.

Concision

Concision is respect for the reader. Shorter, cleaner sentences hold attention. Meaning rises. Voice survives. Every word earns a seat or gives up the chair.

Trim habits that slow the page

Start with the usual suspects. They waste space and blunt force.

• Filler words. very, really, actually, literally, basically, probably. Sweep them. If a sentence weakens after removal, choose a sharper noun or verb.
• Throat clearing. Phrases like “it is important to note,” “in my opinion,” “the fact is.” Cut the preamble. Say the thing.
• Redundant pairs. each and every, first and foremost, various different, past history. Keep one.
• Tautologies. free gift, future plans, end result, completely unique. Trim the echo.

Quick exercise. Read this aloud.

Before: In my opinion, it is important to note that the meeting was very successful.

After: The meeting succeeded.

Notice the leap in pace. No loss of meaning. No loss of tone.

Strengthen verbs, retire nominalizations

Long nouns built from verbs bloat sentences. Verbs move faster.

• make a decision, decide
• provide an explanation, explain
• conduct an analysis, analyze
• give consideration to, consider
• have a conversation with, talk with
• offer support to, support

Before: The team made a decision to move forward with the rollout.

After: The team decided to roll out.

Before: We conducted an analysis of the survey results.

After: We analyzed the survey results.

Set a timer for five minutes. Hunt for of after long nouns. Change to a clean verb where sense allows.

Streamline modifiers and intensifiers

Stacked adjectives add weight without adding meaning. One precise word beats a pile.

• very small, tiny or small
• extremely angry, furious or angry
• absolutely essential, essential
• completely finished, finished

Before: She gave a very quick, brief little summary.

After: She gave a summary.

If tone needs color, add one exact detail. Summary of what, to whom, and why. Precision gives energy. Padding drains it.

Dialogue and stage directions

Readers feel rhythm through talk and action. Repetition muddies the beat.

• Trim redundant tags. If a line reads clearly, drop he said or she asked.
• Cut stacked beats. Shrugged twice, smiled three times, nodded every line. Choose one gesture, not a tic.
• Fold obvious action into the line or leave it out.

Before:

He shrugged. “I do not know,” he said, shrugging again. He looked at her with a small smile on his face.

After:

“I do not know.” He smiled.

Before:

“I am sorry,” she apologized.

After:

“I am sorry.”

Sentences that wander

Long sentences with one idea, good. Long sentences with three ideas, slow. Split where sense changes.

Before: The report, which was completed late last night after several rounds of revision by the committee members who were still working in the office, will be sent to the clients in the morning for review and feedback.

After: The committee finished the report last night. The team will send it to clients in the morning for review.

Two sentences, clearer load. If a clause repeats known information, delete the clause.

Paragraphs with extra baggage

A tight paragraph holds one unit of thought. Everything else belongs next door or nowhere.

• Lead with a strong topic sentence.
• Remove sentences that restate the topic sentence.
• Combine twin sentences. If wording repeats with minor variation, keep the sharper version.

Target a small cut. Five to ten percent per paragraph makes pages lighter without thinning voice.

Practical searches that pay off

Open Find. Hunt patterns that hide flab.

• “in order to” to “to”
• “due to the fact that” to “because”
• “there is” or “there are” at sentence openings. Replace with a subject.
• “the fact” and “as a matter of”
• “begin to” and “start to.” Often the verb alone works.
• “really,” “very,” “actually,” “literally,” “basically,” “probably” for deletion or replacement
• “that” after reporting verbs, such as said or argued. Delete if rhythm holds.

Try this swap list:

• “make use of” to “use”
• “take into account” to “consider”
• “at this point in time” to “now”
• “has the ability to” to “can do” or “does,” though avoid can in your own prose if house style calls for fewer helpers
• “in terms of” to a specific noun or delete

One caution. Some “that”s earn their keep. If removal breeds confusion, keep the word.

Keep rhythm after trimming

Short sentences punch. A page of only short sentences tires the ear. Vary length.

• Pair a crisp line with a graceful follow-up.
• Let one long sentence stand where nuance needs room.
• Avoid a drumbeat of staccato cuts.

Read aloud. Ears catch choppiness faster than eyes. If the page starts to tick, restore one connective phrase or combine two sentences.

A five-minute concision drill

• Pick one page.
• Delete three fillers. very, really, actually, literally, basically.
• Replace two nominalizations with verbs.
• Shorten one sentence by cutting a clause with no new information.
• Split one overloaded sentence into two.
• Read the page aloud. Adjust for rhythm.

Before-and-after set

1. Before: There are several different reasons that we decided to postpone the launch.

   After: We postponed the launch for several reasons.

2. Before: The team will make an effort to reach out to customers in order to gather feedback.

   After: The team will contact customers to gather feedback.

3. Before: It is important to note that our policy at this point in time is under review.

   After: Our policy is under review.

4. Before: The novel features a dark, moody, atmospheric, brooding setting.

   After: The novel features a brooding setting.

5. Before: She started to walk toward the door, and then she began to run.

   After: She walked to the door, then ran.

When not to cut

Voice matters. Humor matters. A repeated phrase might signal character or tone. Leave flourishes that do real work. Trim where words stall meaning, not where words add personality.

Concision speeds the read and sharpens thought. Line by line, small cuts pay off. Pages breathe. Meaning lands. Readers stay with you to the end.

Coherence and Completeness

Coherence keeps ideas in line. Completeness ensures nothing important goes missing. Together they move readers through a book without a stumble.

Build clean logic

Readers follow cause and effect. Give them links they can see.

• Make reasons explicit. Because, so, therefore, even so. Short signposts earn trust.
• Keep one idea per sentence unless tight links exist.
• Maintain parallel structure in lists and arguments.

Before: Sales dropped. Marketing increased spend. The CEO announced layoffs.

After: Sales dropped, so marketing increased spend. Even so, the CEO announced layoffs.

Before: Our goals are to grow revenue, reduce costs, and customer satisfaction.

After: Our goals are to grow revenue, reduce costs, and raise customer satisfaction.

For transitions between sections, offer a hand. One short line that frames the next move saves the reader from guesswork. Example: Next, a quick look at the numbers.

Fiction: continuity that holds

Scene by scene, readers track goals, stakes, and consequences. Missing links break trust.

• Goals. What does the viewpoint character want in this scene, and why now.
• Conflict. Who or what stands in the way.
• Outcome. Win, loss, or shift. Seed the next turn.

Keep an eye on time and space.

• Clock. Morning does not turn into night between two lines unless a scene break signals the change.
• Location. A chair on stage does not vanish. A glass refills only if someone pours.
• Body. A broken wrist does not lift a suitcase on the next page. Scars do not jump sides.
• Gear. Lost keys do not start a car in the next chapter.
• Names and details. Nicknames, eye color, car model, rank, uniform details. Hold steady.

Quick fix set:

Before: She locks her phone in her desk in chapter two. Three pages later she sends a text from the car.

After: She unlocks the desk on her way out, grabs the phone, then sends a text from the car.

Before: He limps through the hallway, then sprints down the stairs.

After: He limps through the hallway, then braces on the rail and hurries down the stairs.

Track reveals. If a character knows a secret on page 40, dialogue on page 30 must not assume that knowledge. A small timeline note beside each scene helps.

Mini exercise. Pick one scene. Write three bullets: goal, obstacle, outcome. Read the scene. Do the lines reflect those bullets in order.

Nonfiction: structure that holds

Arguments have steps. Reports have parts. Readers need a clear map.

• Headings. Follow a clean hierarchy. H1 for chapter, H2 for sections, H3 for subsections. Do not skip levels.
• Parallel headings. Use consistent grammar. For example, all gerunds, or all imperatives.
• Topic sentences. Each section opens with a clear purpose.
• Lists. Keep structure parallel. Start each bullet with the same form.

Cross-references must match.

• Every “see chapter 7” points to chapter 7.
• “See Figure 2.3” must link to a figure labeled 2.3 and a caption that matches the mention.
• If text says “table below,” place the table below or change the wording.

Before: As shown in Figure 2.3, the trend reversed in 2019. The figure is labeled 2.2.

After: As shown in Figure 2.2, the trend reversed in 2019. Or renumber the figure to 2.3.

Completeness checks for nonfiction:

• All tables, figures, sidebars, and appendices exist in files.
• Captions are unique and informative.
• Source notes appear where needed.
• Equations and examples are numbered consistently.
• Footnotes or endnotes match callouts and follow house style.
• Citations and references line up, names and years match across text and list.

Reverse outline trick. Take each heading and write one line that states the claim. If two lines repeat, merge. If a jump appears, insert a short bridge or a new subhead.

Production readiness

Readers judge a book before page one. Front matter and back matter need the same care as chapters.

Front matter, typical items:

• Title page with author name and publisher info
• Copyright page with year, rights, and ISBN
• Dedication, if present
• Epigraph, styled per house rules, with source
• Contents page that matches headings and page numbers
• Lists of figures and tables, if used
• Preface or foreword, labeled correctly
• Acknowledgments, placed per house rules

Back matter, typical items:

• Appendices
• Notes
• Glossary or list of abbreviations
• Bibliography or references
• Index, if planned
• About the author or author bio

Permissions need a home. Quotes from songs, poems, long excerpts, and brand names often need clearance. Flag anything risky.

Practical tools and habits

A few habits save hours and prevent rework.

• Map beats or headings. For fiction, one line per scene with time, place, goal, and outcome. For nonfiction, one line per section with claim and support.
• Validate every callout. “See chapter 7,” “see Figure 2.3,” “Appendix B.” Fix mismatches early.
• Run a cross-reference sweep. In Word, apply Heading styles, then insert cross-references. Update fields before delivery.
• Check numbering systems. Chapters, figures, tables, endnotes. One rule, followed everywhere.
• Hunt placeholders. TK, XX, [add], ???. Replace or flag.
• Align captions and text. If captions use sentence case, match that choice in mentions. If captions end with periods, match that choice as well.
• Confirm all elements are supplied. High-res images, tables in edit-friendly format, math set as text or in an equation editor per house rules.
• Keep a parking lot of bigger issues. Structural problems belong in a note to the author or to a line or developmental editor. Do not patch with a comma.

Actionable checks

• Map chapter or scene beats, or build a heading outline, to test flow and logic.
• Validate every cross-reference and callout, and fix labels or wording as needed.
• Create or review a checklist for front matter and back matter against house style.
• Compare notes, references, figures, and tables line by line with callouts.
• When a structural hole shows up, escalate rather than patching over the gap.

Coherence makes reading feel smooth. Completeness prevents confusion. Nail both, and readers stop thinking about the book’s plumbing. The message stands front and center, where it belongs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Download FREE ebook

Claim your free eBook today and join over 25,000 writers who have read and benefited from this ebook.

'It is probably one of the best books on writing I've read so far.' Miz Bent

Leave this empty

Get free book