different types of book editing

Different Types Of Book Editing

Understanding the Editing Spectrum

Editing works best as a sequence. Big questions first. Sentences next. Then rules and consistency. Final typos on designed pages. Skip ahead and you pay twice.

Here is the shape of the work.

Each stage has a purpose. Respect the order and the work goes faster, cheaper, and with less pain.

Pick rules early and stick with them

Choose a style guide before copyediting begins. Chicago Manual of Style with US spelling, or New Oxford Style Manual with UK spelling. Record the choice at the top of the manuscript or in a briefing note. Add preferences for serial commas, number treatment, and capitalization. Early choices prevent reversals later.

A style sheet grows from those choices. Think of it as the book’s dictionary and rulebook. Names, places, invented terms, italicization, hyphenation, numerals. Your copyeditor builds and maintains this document. Share it with everyone on the team, including the designer and proofreader.

Fix structure before polishing prose

No amount of elegant sentences will rescue a broken structure. Solve plot holes and argument gaps first. Move chapters, merge sections, cut dead weight, write missing scenes. Only then invite someone to refine voice and rhythm.

A quick test helps. Summarize the book in one sentence. If that sentence keeps changing, stay in developmental mode. Another test. Create a scene or chapter map with one line per unit. If the map shows repetition or sag, address those areas before line work.

Keep the voice, raise the clarity

Good editing preserves personality. A sharp editor improves clarity, pacing, coherence, and reader engagement without sanding off voice. Expect questions in the margins. Who needs to know this now. What promise does this chapter make. Where does the energy drop. Those queries are not nitpicks. Those queries protect the reader’s experience while respecting your sound on the page.

Two quick examples.

Deliverables to expect and how to use them

Stay in sequence to save time and budget

Avoid copyediting or proofreading while the manuscript keeps changing. Every structural fix creates ripple effects. New scenes bring new continuity problems. Rearranged chapters scramble references and cross-links. Lock structure, then refine sentences, then enforce rules, then check designed pages for small errors.

One last sanity check before each handoff.

Editing done in order feels almost calm. You know what each pass will solve, what each document will deliver, and how every step serves the reader without drowning your voice.

Core Types of Book Editing

Four edits, four goals. Know which hat your editor wears before you hit Send.

Developmental editing

Purpose: build or repair the spine of the book. Structure, argument, plot, character arcs, pacing, theme, chapter order. This stage asks big questions and gives you a roadmap.

What you receive

What it solves

Quick exercise

What it does not do

Line editing

Purpose: raise prose to its best expression. Voice, rhythm, word choice, imagery, transitions, paragraph logic, tone. This is where pages begin to sing without losing your sound.

What you receive

What it solves

Tiny example

Another example

Quick exercise

What it does not do

Copyediting

Purpose: correctness and consistency. Grammar, punctuation, spelling, usage, continuity, and adherence to style. Think of this pass as guardrails for the reader’s brain.

What you receive

What it solves

Style sheet highlights

Quick example

What it does not do

Proofreading

Purpose: final quality check on designed pages after typesetting. Words sit in their boxes now, so you review pages, not a Word file.

What you receive

What it solves

How to read proofs

What it does not do

Pick the right pass for the problem in front of you. The work moves faster, your budget goes further, and your voice stays yours.

Specialized and Adjacent Services

These services sit beside the core edits. They save money, sharpen intent, and reduce surprises later. Pick the one that matches the stage you are in.

Manuscript assessment, critique

Purpose: a fast diagnosis before deep edits. You get a clear read on strengths, risks, and next steps.

What you receive

When to choose it

What it looks at

Quick exercise

What it does not include

Book coaching

Purpose: ongoing support during drafting. Guidance, accountability, and skill building in real time.

What you receive

When to choose it

A week in practice

What it does not include

Sensitivity and authenticity reading

Purpose: review representation and cultural content for accuracy and respect. The reader brings lived experience or deep expertise.

What you receive

When to choose it

Good practice

What it does not include

Fact-checking and permissions, nonfiction

Purpose: protect trust and reduce risk. Quotes, data, names, dates, sources, and rights.

What you receive

Typical checks

When to start

What it does not include

Technical and academic editing

Purpose: precision and standards. Terminology, tables, equations, figures, and citations that meet the target style.

What you receive

Sample fixes

When to choose it

What it does not include

Indexing, nonfiction

Purpose: a usable back-of-book index that serves readers and librarians. Built from final pages, not from a draft.

What you receive

How a good index reads

When to schedule

What it does not include

A quick way to choose

How the Editorial Process Flows

Editing works best in order. Big picture first. Sentences next. Mechanics after that. Typos last. Skip a step and you pay for it later.

The sequence, at a glance

  1. Manuscript assessment, optional

    A quick diagnosis. You get an editorial letter with strengths, risks, and priorities. No fine-tooth edits.

  2. Developmental edit

    Structure, argument, plot, pacing, chapter order. Expect an editorial letter plus an annotated file. You revise before anything else moves.

  3. Author revision

    You rewrite with a plan. Lock structure. Stabilize point of view and tense. Trim scenes or sections that do not serve the spine.

  4. Line edit

    Voice, rhythm, word choice, paragraph logic, transitions. Tracked changes with comments that explain reasoning.

  5. Copyedit

    Grammar, punctuation, usage, continuity, consistency. A style sheet guides decisions. You approve queries, then freeze wording.

  6. Typesetting and layout

    Your clean text goes into design. Fonts, margins, headings, images. No rewriting here, only necessary tweaks.

  7. Proofreading

    A final check on designed pages. Typos, bad line breaks, widows and orphans, captions, folios, glitches. Fixes go back to design, then files ship.

How many passes and how much time

Plan one or two passes per stage. Build a buffer between stages for your revision. Rushing invites new errors.

A simple model for an 80,000-word novel

Shorter books move faster. Heavy research or complex structure slows the pace. Book in advance, since good editors schedule months out.

Tools that keep work clean

Mini tip

Before you review edits, change Word view to Simple Markup. Read for flow. Then toggle All Markup for decision mode.

Version control that saves headaches

Name files with version, date, and initials. Keep an Archive folder and a Current folder.

Examples

Rules to live by

Hand-offs and communication

Set a kickoff call at each major stage. Agree on scope, priorities, and dates. Decide how queries will be handled, in comments or in a separate memo.

When you return a revision, include a short note

During proofreading, report errors with precise references

Clarity keeps momentum high and tempers cool.

For self-publishing and indie authors

Editing lives inside a larger production plan. Link your edits to design and launch dates.

A lean timeline for an early-summer release

Build slack into every month. Printers slip. Life intrudes. A small cushion protects quality.

Common bottlenecks and how to avoid them

A quick planning exercise

Open a calendar. Mark hard dates you cannot move, such as a conference or seasonal tie-in. Count backward using the sequence above. Add one buffer week after each stage. Now send inquiries to editors with your window, word count, genre, and goals. Clear plans attract clear yeses.

Do the right work at the right time. Your future self, and your readers, will thank you.

Choosing the Right Edit and Editor

Start with symptoms. Match the pain to the fix. Spend money where progress happens.

Quick self-diagnosis

Answer yes or no.

Still unsure? Write one sentence named goal for the next pass. Example: clarify protagonist’s desire in acts one and two. If the goal mentions structure or logic, go developmental. If the goal mentions rhythm or tone, go line. If the goal mentions consistency or correctness, go copyedit. If the goal mentions typos on a PDF, go proofread.

Vet expertise, not vibes

Look for a match in genre and audience. A great thriller editor might miss romance beats. A children’s specialist might not suit academic prose.

Ask for proof of fit.

Gauge communication style. You want clear notes, respectful tone, and firm reasoning. Request examples of margin queries or editorial letters.

Request a sample edit

Send one to two pages from a representative section. Middle chapters work well. Avoid a prologue or a polished excerpt.

Share a brief brief.

Ask for tracked changes plus a few comments. Review the sample like a coach. Do suggestions improve clarity and flow? Do edits keep your voice? Do comments explain reasoning without rewriting the book in the editor’s voice?

Two strong signs

Define scope in writing

No surprises, no muddle. Lock the basics before work begins.

Include

Ask for a one-paragraph summary of approach. Plain English beats jargon.

Rates and timelines, without guesswork

Request a total project fee and an equivalent per-word figure. Ask for an hourly estimate for out-of-scope add-ons. Confirm how holidays and sick days affect dates. Get agreement on response times for queries.

Good editors book months ahead. Hold a slot with a deposit, then protect that slot by delivering pages on time.

Red flags to avoid

Trust your gut, then verify with paper.

A short outreach template

Subject: Line edit inquiry for 82k-word fantasy novel, US English, Chicago

Hello [Name],

I am seeking a line edit on a completed fantasy novel, 82,000 words, first person, present tense. Structure is stable. Goals for this pass, tighten rhythm, sharpen dialogue, and smooth POV shifts. Style guide, Chicago, US spelling.

Would you share availability, a project quote, and a one-page sample edit on two pages from chapter 8? I will send a Word file with Track Changes on. If the fit works, I am ready to place a deposit to hold a late March start.

Thank you,
[Your Name]
[Website or one-line bio]

One last check before you hire

Revisit the sample, the scope, and the timeline. Confirm that the editor heard your goals. Confirm that the plan matches your stage. Then say yes, and clear the path for focused work.

Preparing Your Manuscript for Each Stage

Preparation saves time. Preparation saves money. Clean files let editors focus on the work you want done, not untangling formatting or tracking down names.

Universal setup

Aim for standard format.

Housekeeping helps.

Mini-exercise, run a spelling search for double spaces and tabs. Replace with proper spacing and styles.

Before a developmental edit

A structural pass benefits from context. Help your editor see the whole.

Provide

Add reader input.

Help your own focus.

Trim distractions.

Before a line edit

Line work shines when structure holds firm. Lock the bones, then address voice and rhythm.

Stabilize core choices.

Light grooming first.

Give the editor a clear brief.

Quick test, read three pages aloud. Mark every spot where breath runs short or sense blurs. Fix obvious snags before handing over.

Before a copyedit

Correctness and consistency drive this stage. Decisions first, then lists.

Decide conventions.

Build references.

Tidy the text.

Legal sanity check.

Before proofreading

Proofreading happens on designed pages. No rewriting at this stage. Freeze the text before layout, then mark only true errors after layout.

Prepare files.

Coordinate with design.

Run a layout checklist.

Mark changes clearly.

Final tip, name this version with a freeze date, then avoid new text between proof rounds. Everyone sleeps better, and the book leaves the house clean.

Frequently Asked Questions

In what order should I run editing passes and why does the sequence matter?

Follow the ladder: developmental edit, author revision, line edit, copyedit, then proofreading on laid-out pages. Each pass fixes a different class of problem, so doing sentence-level polish before structure is stable wastes time and risks rework.

Sequence matters because structural changes cascade into prose and layout; lock the spine first and the sentences you refine will survive cuts, moves and timeline fixes later in production.

How do I decide whether I need a developmental edit, line edit, copyedit or proofread?

Diagnose by symptom: plot holes, sagging middle or muddled argument = developmental edit; clunky sentences, tonal whiplash or repetitive phrasing = line edit; inconsistent spelling, punctuation or name variants = copyedit; typos and bad line breaks on a PDF = proofreading.

Do a quick triage: if you still expect to move chapters, do not copyedit; if you have a designed PDF and see layout glitches, send it to proofreader on PDF galleys.

What should I include in a developmental edit packet?

Provide one clean Word file of the full manuscript, a one-page synopsis, a chapter-by-chapter outline or scene map, and a character roster or key-term list. Add comp titles, target reader notes and two or three specific questions you want the editor to answer.

That packet lets the editor write an effective editorial letter and annotate the manuscript with focused guidance rather than guessing at your intentions or audience.

How should I prepare my manuscript for copyediting (how to prepare a manuscript for copyediting)?

Lock structure and prose first, choose your style guide and spelling variant (for example Chicago Manual of Style with US or Oxford with UK), run spellcheck and build a proper‑noun and special‑term list. Prepare a starter style sheet noting serial comma preference, number rules and hyphenation decisions.

These preflight steps let the copyeditor create a complete style sheet and handle correctness and consistency efficiently, reducing queries and iterative churn.

Why must proofreading be done on PDF galleys and not in Word?

Proofreading inspects text in its final design context: line breaks, pagination, widows, orphans, caption placement and folios. Word cannot reproduce exact pagination or the line breaks introduced by typesetting, so many layout-specific errors only appear on PDF galleys.

Always proofread on designed pages to catch layout glitches and avoid late-stage changes that create new errors and extra cost.

What is a style sheet and how does it help across editing, design and proofing?

A style sheet is the book’s rulebook: it records spelling, hyphenation, number treatment, preferred terms, character name spellings and house choices such as serial comma use. Copyeditors build it and proofreaders and designers consult it to maintain consistency.

Sharing the style sheet keeps everyone aligned, reduces repeated queries and ensures consistent usage in final files and future reprints.

What is a realistic timeline for an 80,000‑word book from developmental edit to proofing?

Expect around 16–18 weeks as a practical estimate: 3–6 weeks for developmental edit, 3–6 weeks for author revision, 2–4 weeks for line editing, 2–3 weeks for copyediting, then layout and 1–2 weeks for proofreading. Allow buffer weeks between passes for clear thinking and query responses.

Timings vary with draft quality, complexity and how quickly the author replies; plan in weeks not days and reserve funds and calendar time for revisions uncovered by each pass.

Writing Manual Cover

Download FREE ebook

Claim your free eBook today and join over 25,000 writers who have read and benefited from this ebook.

'It is probably one of the best books on writing I've read so far.' Miz Bent

Get free book