What Is Line Editing And How It Improves Your Prose

Gary Smailes | 5 November 2025

What Line Editing Is (and Isn’t)

Line editing tunes your sentences. Plot stays put. Argument stays put. The work targets clarity, rhythm, tone, and voice so the page reads clean and alive.

Think of it as the difference between a sturdy table and a table you want in your home. The legs hold, sure. The finish, the joints, the way a hand glides across the surface, that is line work.

Here is what falls inside the scope:

• Diction. Pick the right word, not a cluster of almost-right ones.
• Imagery. Swap fog for focus. Specific nouns, precise verbs.
• Cadence. Sentence length in play with breath and emphasis.
• Paragraph flow. One controlling idea, logical order.
• Transitions. Smooth handoffs between sentences and scenes.
• Concision. Fewer words, stronger meaning.
• Repetition. Echoes trimmed or replaced with fresh phrasing.
• Readability for your audience. Choices that match genre, age, and expectations.

Mini check. Take any paragraph from your draft. Circle every weak verb plus helper, like was walking or began to run. Replace with a single verb. Read aloud. The line tightens, the voice steps forward.

What line editing is not:

• Not a structural overhaul. No scene moves. No new subplot. No reordered argument.
• Not a rules-only pass. Grammar rules matter, but this stage focuses on effect on the reader.
• Not proofreading. Typos still slip by here. A later pass hunts them down.

Where the other stages sit:

• Developmental editing covers the bones. Plot, pacing, character arcs, argument order.
• Copyediting checks grammar, usage, punctuation, and style consistency. Chicago or AP, guided by a style sheet.
• Proofreading comes last, a final net for typos and formatting glitches.

You hire the right stage for the right problem. If readers say the middle sags, wrong stage. If readers say the pages feel clunky, line work will help.

How line editing touches fiction

Fiction lives through point of view, emotion, and flow. Line edits press on those levers.

• POV depth. Fewer filter words like she saw or he felt. More direct experience.
  • Before: She felt a chill run down her back as the door creaked.
  • After: Cold slid down her spine. The door creaked.
• Emotional resonance. Concrete cues over labels.
  • Before: He was angry.
  • After: His jaw clicked. The glass trembled in his hand.
• Narrative flow. Varied sentence lengths, clear beats, clean exits and entries.
  • Before: The alley was dark. She went into it and then she heard a noise behind her that frightened her.
  • After: The alley swallowed the light. She stepped in. Footsteps fell behind her.

How line editing strengthens nonfiction

Nonfiction thrives on clarity, logic, and authority. Line edits serve those goals.

• Claims and support. Each sentence advances the point or sets up the next.
  • Before: There are a lot of reasons for teams to fail which are mainly because of communication problems.
  • After: Teams fail for one main reason. Poor communication.
• Transitions. Smooth links between sentences, not leaps.
  • Before: We launched three pilots. The board asked for a report. The data was mixed.
  • After: We launched three pilots. When the board asked for a report, we showed mixed data and a plan to refine the winner.
• Tone fit. Diction that suits audience and brand. Academic, trade, executive brief, all need different weight.

A quick before and after tour

• Wordiness trimmed
  • Before: She quickly ran down the very long hallway.
  • After: She sprinted down the corridor.
• Vague pronouns made clear
  • Before: They said it would help, which was surprising.
  • After: The nurses promised relief. The promise surprised her.
• Repetition cut
  • Before: The meeting was long, and the long meeting drained the team.
  • After: The meeting dragged and drained the team.
• Paragraph focus restored
  • Before: Our app helps users save money, and the team worked hard last year, which shows our commitment, and we are excited about the next version.
  • After: Our app helps users save money. Last year the team shipped weekly. The next version builds on that momentum.

A simple exercise

Take one page. Mark these in the margin:

• W for weak verb strings, such as was going to try.
• F for filter words, such as I realized, he noticed, she saw.
• R for repeated words or ideas.

Revise W items with a single strong verb. Cut F items by moving sensation into the sentence. Replace R items with leaner phrasing or delete duplicates. Read aloud. You will hear the lift.

Protecting your voice

Line editing does not flatten voice. Done well, it reveals voice. An editor will flag lines where rhythm sings so later changes avoid dulling them. The goal is cohesion, not sameness. If your noir voice wants grit, the edit preserves grit while removing sludge.

A quick test for fit with an editor. Ask for a sample on a voicey page. If the result reads like someone else wrote it, keep looking. If it reads like you on your best day, you found a match.

Action

Pick one goal for the next pass, such as voice cohesion, clarity, or concision. Share the goal with your editor so the edit stays focused.

How Line Editing Improves Your Prose

Line work makes sentences pull their weight. Same scenes or arguments, sharper delivery. You feel the lift in the mouth when you read aloud. Fewer trips, cleaner landings.

Clarity and concision

Readers forgive many things. Murk is not one of them. A line edit trims filler, vague qualifiers, and flabby phrasing so meaning hits fast.

• Before: She quickly ran down the very long hallway.
• After: She sprinted down the corridor.
• Before: Due to the fact that the results were unclear, we decided to wait.
• After: Because the results were unclear, we waited.
• Before: He was starting to feel like he might be late.
• After: He would be late.

Try this. Open one page. Highlight every was -ing verb string, every began to, and every phrase with in order to. Revise with a single precise verb. Read it aloud. Notice how the paragraph breathes.

Rhythm and flow

Good prose has a beat. Not a metronome, a pulse. Long, short, short, long. A line edit watches the sequence so your reader never stumbles.

• Before: The storm started. We ran to the car. The keys were missing. We looked for them. Time was short.
• After: Thunder cracked. We ran for the car. No keys. We tore through pockets. Time slipped.

When a section drags, check sentence openings. If five lines start with he, she, or I, vary the entry. If every sentence stretches across the page, break one. If every sentence is a jab, add one with a sweep.

Voice and tone

Your voice should sound like you, only cleaner. Line edits tune diction to match genre and audience while guarding the flavor of your prose.

• Literary vibe
  • Before: The night was really dark, and she felt sad about the past.
  • After: Night pressed in. Memory pressed harder.
• Commercial thriller
  • Before: He moved quickly through the space between the buildings.
  • After: He cut through the alley.
• Business article
  • Before: Our team is laser-focused on growth, which is important for our mission.
  • After: Growth supports our mission. Here is how we will get there.

If an edit makes your pages sound like a stranger, speak up. A good line editor explains choices and keeps your signature intact.

Show vs tell at the line level

No need to banish telling. You need the right balance. A line edit nudges bland statements toward specific, sensory action.

• Before: He was very angry.
• After: His jaw locked. The glass rattled in his fist.
• Before: The room was messy.
• After: Socks draped the chair. A plate glued to the desk with dried sauce.
• Before: The product launch was successful.
• After: The launch sold out in three hours. Support tickets stayed under ten.

Ask yourself, what would a camera catch, what would a mic pick up, what would skin feel. Write that.

Echoes and redundancy

Writers fall in love with certain words. Readers notice. A line edit trims echoes and recycles only by design.

• Before: The plan was simple. The simple plan worked because it was simple.
• After: The plan was simple. It worked.
• Before: She nodded. He nodded. They nodded again.
• After: She nodded. He rolled a shoulder and looked away.

Clichés creep in during drafting. Replace them with something grounded in your scene or subject. Instead of cold as ice, try a concrete cue, such as breath frosting the mirror.

Readability

Strong ideas drown in tangled syntax. Line edits unwind the knot, fix pronoun drift, and restore paragraph focus.

• Before: When Nina told Lena she should talk to her manager, she said she would, which surprised her.
• After: Nina urged Lena to talk to her manager. Lena agreed, which surprised Nina.
• Before: There is a belief among leaders that meetings are where decisions are made.
• After: Many leaders believe meetings make decisions.
• Before: Our platform reduces costs, and we had a great quarter, and we are building new features that will help customers and make everyone excited.
• After: Our platform reduces costs. Last quarter ended strong. Next quarter brings three features for customers.

One paragraph, one controlling idea. If you feel tugged in two directions, split the paragraph.

A quick pass you can run today

Build a watch list. Ten items. Your worst tics. Examples to consider:

• Filter words, such as she saw, he felt, I realized.
• Weak hedges, such as somewhat, kind of, perhaps.
• Filler, such as that, just, really.
• Pet gestures, such as shrug, grin, sigh.
• Crutch verbs, such as was, went, got, put.
• Overused sentence starters, such as And, But, So.
• Nominalizations, such as make a decision, give an answer.

Now run a targeted pass. Search and destroy in batches. Read aloud after each batch. Do not chase everything at once. Focus wins.

Line editing does not bolt on brilliance. It reveals the strength already inside your lines. Clean sentences. Clear beats. A voice readers trust. You do the heavy lifting in the draft. A tight line pass brings the work into crisp focus.

Where Line Editing Fits in the Editing Process

Line editing sits in the middle of the work. Big-picture questions first. Surface polish last. Words get sharp once the story or argument stands firm.

The sequence that saves time and money

Think of four passes in order. Developmental edit, then line edit, then copyedit, then proofreading. Structure, then sentences, then rules, then typos.

Polish too early and you pay twice. I once spent a week smoothing a tense chase scene. Clean, tight, strong. Two weeks later, the author cut the subplot. That invoice hurt. Hold the sanding until the furniture stops moving.

Signs you’re ready for a line edit

Look for stability. Not perfection. Stability.

• No planned scene-level rewrites. You might tweak a beat, not move three chapters.
• Timeline holds. Stakes track from scene to scene. Throughline reads clear.
• Beta readers mark phrases like clunky, flat, hard to follow. They are not asking where the plot went.
• Your chapter order feels right. You are not reaching for index cards at midnight.
• You know the book’s promise to the reader. You know where each section delivers on that promise.

Quick test. Summarize each chapter in one sentence. If you struggle to state the point, you are still in developmental territory.

If you’re not ready, keep building

If big questions remain, pause the line edit. Common flags:

• You are still unsure what your protagonist wants.
• The midpoint sags. The ending feels unearned.
• The argument jumps. Logic hinges on a missing step.
• You plan to cut or add whole sections.

Fix those first. A tight sentence will not rescue a broken spine.

Two simple checks help. Map scene goals on sticky notes, one per scene. Read them down the wall. If tension drops for three scenes in a row, restructure. For nonfiction, pull topic sentences into a list. If the list fails to build a case, reorder before you polish.

Short-form exceptions

Essays and short stories often benefit from a hybrid pass. Brief structural notes, then line work in the same round. Short pieces allow fast reshaping without derailing the polish. You get comments like Move this paragraph up front, then sentence-level edits that sharpen tone and rhythm.

When does a hybrid pass serve you well?

• Op-eds and time-sensitive essays that need clarity, authority, and speed.
• Short stories with a clear arc that need a tighter point of view and cleaner beats.
• Personal essays where structure sits close to voice, so line changes reveal structure needs.

If the piece sprawls past five thousand words, split the work. A quick structural skim first, then line edit once the frame holds.

Action: freeze before you polish

Lock the draft before a line edit. Freeze major cuts and additions so you do not pay to shine pages you plan to delete.

Use a simple checklist:

• Finalize chapter order and section headings.
• Mark scenes for deletion in a separate list. Delete them before the edit starts.
• Resolve timeline and character ages.
• Confirm names, terms, and key facts. No pending decisions on labels or titles.
• Write a one-paragraph brief that states audience, goal, and tone target. Share it.

Create a version name that signals commitment. Example, Book_v7_READY_FOR_LINE_EDIT. Then leave the draft alone. If a new idea pounds on the door, jot a note in a parking lot file. Revisit after the line pass.

You do not need a flawless draft for a line edit. You need a stable one. Once the bones hold, sentence work pays off. The result, pages that read clean and confident, with zero wasted effort.

Working with a Line Editor: Deliverables, Workflow, and Costs

You hire a line editor for sentences, so expect sentence-level feedback you feel in your fingers. Clean pages. Clear notes. No mystery.

What you receive

Most editors deliver four pieces.

• Tracked changes in Word or Google Docs. You see every cut and tweak. Accept or reject with a click.
• Margin comments that explain the move. Notes like Tighten this opener or Strong verb here. Expect questions where only you decide. For example, Is this tone too sharp for your audience.
• A style sheet. Spelling choices, hyphenation, capitalization, character names, place names, terms, and any pet rules. This keeps voice steady across chapters.
• A short summary. Patterns to watch, tics to trim, and a plan for your next pass.

Ask for a one-page sample of each deliverable. You want edits that keep your voice, not edits that flatten it.

How the process runs

Think in stages.

1. Sample edit, five to ten pages. Pick a representative section. A middle chapter works well. If the opening has a different style, send both. You want proof of voice protection, not a showcase of your strongest pages.
2. Agreement on scope. Decide on one full pass or two. Pin down what falls in and what stays out. For example, line work only, not developmental fixes. Or, light structural nudges welcome in short pieces.
3. The pass. Edits arrive with queries for author decisions. Expect a steady rhythm. You answer questions, the editor moves forward, you receive a batch each week, or one delivery at the end. Set expectations early.
4. Optional debrief call. Thirty to sixty minutes. Review patterns, talk through open questions, agree on next steps.
5. Light check on revised pages. A quick review of your revisions. This helps catch fresh seams and reintroductions of old tics.

A small tip. During the pass, keep a parking lot file for new ideas. Resist mid-edit rewrites outside of queries. Big changes break momentum and cost money.

Timelines and scheduling

For a book-length project, plan two to four weeks for the edit, then your revision time on top. Shorter projects move faster, but still need space for decisions. The best schedule leaves room for thinking, not rush approval.

Add buffers. Hardware fails. Children get sick. Clutch scenes demand an extra day. Protect the calendar and the work will thank you.

Pricing and what affects rate

Rates often fall between 0.01 and 0.04 dollars per word. A few examples:

• 80,000 words at 0.02 per word equals 1,600 dollars.
• 100,000 words at 0.03 per word equals 3,000 dollars.

What pushes a quote higher:

• Dense prose with many edits per page.
• Hybrid work that mixes structural notes with line work.
• Heavy worldbuilding or technical terms that require research.
• Compressed schedule.

Ask about billing structure. Deposit amount, payment milestones, and refund policy. Clarity removes stress later.

How to evaluate fit

A line editor touches every sentence. You want a partner who sharpens voice, not a voice swap.

Questions to ask:

• Show before and after pages from work in my genre.
• What principles guide your line choices.
• How do you protect voice while cutting filler and smoothing rhythm.
• Will you flag places where writer intent stays unclear, rather than guessing.
• Do you edit for this genre often. Fiction, memoir, academic, business.

Read the margin comments closely. Look for specific notes, not vague advice. You want edits that sound like you on your best day.

A quick test. After a sample, read the revised page aloud. If the page sounds like your voice, only cleaner, you have a match.

How to be a strong client

Editors love clarity.

• Share a brief. Audience, comp titles, pain points, tone targets, and three adjectives you never want in your prose. For example, snarky, cutesy, preachy.
• State goals for this pass. Voice cohesion, clarity, concision, or another focus. One goal per pass works best.
• Confirm rounds and scope in writing. One pass or two, light check on revisions or none.
• Agree on deadlines and communication cadence. Weekly updates or milestone emails.
• Provide a clean, stable draft. Freeze cuts and additions before the edit begins.

Here is a simple email template you can adapt:

Subject: Line edit brief for [Project Title]

Hi [Editor Name],

Here is the project brief for our line edit.

• Audience: [target readers]
• Goal: [what the book promises readers]
• Tone targets: [three to five words]
• Watch list: [top tics or phrasing to trim]
• Genre comps: [two or three titles]
• Scope: [one or two passes, light check on revisions if agreed]
• Schedule: [start date, delivery target, debrief preference]

Thanks,
[Your Name]

A good brief saves rounds. You get fewer surprises and stronger pages.

You do not need a famous editor. You need a thoughtful partner who edits toward your voice and your reader. Get the deliverables you expect, agree on the workflow, and pay for work that moves the book forward. That mix turns line editing into momentum, not a stall.

DIY Line-Editing Techniques to Polish Your Draft

The good news. Most messy lines respond to a few simple moves. Work in short, targeted passes. Fix one thing at a time, then rest your eyes.

Read it aloud

Your mouth hears what your eyes miss.

• Read a printed page or use text-to-speech.
• Mark any stumble, long windup, or unintentional rhyme.
• Listen for three things: breath, music, meaning. If you lose breath, the sentence runs long. If the music is flat, vary length. If meaning blurs, rewrite.

Mini exercise:

• Pick one page.
• Read it aloud, pen in hand.
• Put a slash where you inhale. One slash per sentence is a good signal. More slashes means a trim.

Tighten sentences

Small cuts, big lift.

• Swap weak verb plus adverb for a precise verb.
  • Ran quickly to sprinted.
  • Spoke softly to murmured.
  • Looked closely to inspected.
• Convert nominalizations.
  • Made a decision to decided.
  • Gave a description to described.
  • Had an influence to influenced.
• Cut empty openers.
  • There were candles on the table to Candles lined the table.
  • It was clear that he lied to He lied.
• Watch false starts.
  • In order to to To.
  • Due to the fact to Because.
  • The fact is to delete.

Mini exercise:

• Take one paragraph.
• Bold every verb. Replace two weak ones with precise verbs.
• Delete three words that add no meaning. Read again.

Strengthen POV and specificity

Bring the reader inside the moment.

• Reduce filter words. Common offenders: saw, heard, felt, noticed, realized, thought, wondered, began to, started to.
  • She saw the door open to The door opened.
  • He felt a chill to A chill ran up his arms.
  • I realized I was late to I was late.
• Anchor detail in perspective.
  • Vague: A nice car pulled up.
  • Specific in character voice: A dented Civic coughed into the space. Or, for a status-obsessed narrator, A base-model Civic wheezed into my spot.
• Swap placeholders for concrete nouns.
  • Vague: He grabbed some stuff.
  • Specific: He grabbed the passport and the ring box.

Nonfiction tweak:

• Replace abstract labels with measurable terms.
  • Vague: The results were significant.
  • Clear: The response rate rose from 12 percent to 19 percent.

Mini exercise:

• Search your doc for saw, felt, realized, noticed, started, began.
• Revise five hits without the filter.

Manage cadence

Readers feel rhythm before they parse it.

• Vary length with intention.
  • Short lines punch.
  • Long lines gather nuance.
  • Mix them for flow.
• Group for effect.
  • Build with two longer sentences.
  • Land the beat with a short one.
• Fix choppy starts.
  • Too many sentences opening with I or He or She makes a drumbeat. Flip structure now and then.
  • Example: I packed my bag. I checked the map. I left. Try: After checking the map and packing, I left.
• Keep paragraphs focused.
  • One controlling idea per paragraph.
  • If a sentence wanders, move it or cut it.
  • If a paragraph swells past eight or nine lines, test a split.

Mini exercise:

• Mark S for short and L for long at the end of each sentence on a page.
• If you see S S S S or L L L L, adjust.

Control repetition

Echoes dull the page.

• Build a watch list. Pick ten overused words or gestures. Examples: smile, shrug, look, turn, blink, stare, little, suddenly, really, very. Add your pet metaphors.
• Use search to scan for each watch word. Trim, replace, or rewrite.
• Kill duplicate ideas. If two sentences say the same thing, keep the stronger one.
• Space out distinct words. If a rare word appears twice in a paragraph, change one.

Mini exercise:

• Set a timer for ten minutes.
• Search for smile. Reduce by half without adding new tics.

Nonfiction clarity

Make the promise, then deliver.

• Lead with the point.
  • Before: When considering software options for small teams, there are numerous factors to review. One key factor involves total cost of ownership over time.
  • After: Total cost of ownership matters most for small teams. Then list the factors that change it.
• Use parallel structure in lists.
  • Weak: The policy aims to simplify reporting, improvement of compliance, and making audits faster.
  • Strong: The policy aims to simplify reporting, improve compliance, and speed audits.
• Check relevance.
  • Each sentence must push the claim forward. If a sentence adds color without proof, move it to a case study box or cut it.

Mini exercise:

• Take one section.
• Write a one-line topic sentence for each paragraph.
• If the first sentence does not match the topic sentence, rewrite it.

Use tools, not as a crutch

• ProWritingAid or Grammarly can flag passive voice, long sentences, and repeated words. Treat flags as leads, not orders.
• Word’s Read Aloud exposes clunk.
• Build macros or use highlighters for filler words.
• Keep a style sheet for decisions on spelling, hyphenation, capitalization, character names, and terms.

Quick setup:

• Create a page at the front of your manuscript called Style.
• Add entries as you decide them, like email vs e-mail, wellbeing vs well-being, and whether your narrator writes OK or okay.

Run mini-passes in sequence

One lens per pass keeps the brain sharp.

• Pass 1, clarity. Fix meaning, pronouns, and muddled syntax. If a reader could misread a sentence, rewrite.
• Pass 2, concision. Cut filler, weak openings, and nominalizations.
• Pass 3, cadence. Vary length, tune transitions, split swollen paragraphs.
• Pass 4, voice. Align diction with audience and genre. Remove words your narrator would never say. Add one fresh image where a cliché tried to sneak in.

Time-box each pass. Twenty to thirty minutes, then break. Fresh eyes outrun ego.

Finish with a proof after formatting. Page numbers shift, headings move, and new typos appear when text flows into design. A last slow read keeps gremlins out of print.

Practice builds instinct. After a few rounds, you will start hearing problems as you draft, which makes the next pass lighter and the work more fun.

Frequently Asked Questions

Download FREE ebook

Claim your free eBook today and join over 25,000 writers who have read and benefited from this ebook.

'It is probably one of the best books on writing I've read so far.' Miz Bent

Leave this empty

Get free book