What To Cut During Revision (And What To Keep)

What to Cut During Revision (and What to Keep)

Set Clear Criteria for What Earns Its Place

Cutting works best when you know what earns a seat on the page. Otherwise you snip at random and regret follows. Give every unit a job description, then demand results.

The Two-Job Test

Every paragraph, scene, or section should do at least two jobs. Examples of jobs:

Quick test:

Examples:

Mini exercise, ten minutes:

Write a Short Revision Brief

A one-page brief guides hard choices when fatigue sets in. Keep it visible.

Include:

Sample, novel:

Sample, nonfiction:

Every cut or keep decision answers one question, does this serve the brief.

Build a Style Sheet

Consistency feels like professionalism. A style sheet protects choices across drafts and stops copyediting scrapes later.

Create a simple doc with sections:

Sample entries:

Update after each pass. Future you will cheer.

Make a Reverse Outline

A reverse outline exposes duplicates, orphans, and weak links. Start with what exists, not what you wish existed.

How to build one:

Tiny example:

Now scan:

For nonfiction:

Set Measurable Goals and a Cut Bin

Vague goals drag revision for months. Precise goals create traction.

Pick targets:

Create a Cut Bin file to park removed material. Label with book title and date. Inside, create headers by chapter. Paste cuts under the right header with a quick note, reason and page number. Examples:

Benefits:

Mini routine:

Clear criteria reduce debate and speed decisions. Each page earns a place or steps aside. You move forward lighter, sharper, and in control.

High-Value Cuts Most Drafts Need

Most drafts carry extra weight. Fast gains come from trimming common offenders. Start here.

Throat-clearing openings and preambles

Begin when something changes. Not five paragraphs earlier while warming up.

Quick test:

Example, fiction:

Example, nonfiction:

Scenes or sections with no change

Every scene earns a place by shifting status. Action, stakes, understanding, power, location, goal, something moves.

Tests:

Example:

Nonfiction parallel:

Info-dumps and research dumps

Background matters, but readers want movement first. Thread context through action or argument in short lines.

Fixes:

Example, fiction:

Example, nonfiction:

Redundancies

Saying the same thing twice feels safe during drafting. Readers feel the drag.

Hunt repeats:

Fix:

Mini exercise, ten minutes:

Filler, hedges, and filters

Hedges sap energy. Filters block connection. Expletive openings waste space.

Targets:

Examples:

Weak modifiers and clichés

A strong verb or specific noun beats an adverb–verb pair every time. Clichés numb the page.

Upgrades:

Quick pass:

Over-detailed stage directions and micromovements

Readers do not need every shrug, turn, or door handle. Compress movement to the beats that carry meaning.

Cuts:

Exercise:

Dialogue small talk and on-the-nose exposition

Dialogue earns space through desire, conflict, and subtext. Greetings and weather chat belong to drafting, not to print.

Trim:

Fixes:

Example:

POV drift and head-hopping

Stay inside one mind per scene unless a clear handoff serves the story. Drifting robs tension.

Checks:

Repair:

Unnecessary scene breaks and timeline detours

Frequent cuts fracture flow. Time jumps confuse when anchors go missing.

Fix:

Side characters, examples, or subplots that duplicate function

Two characters doing the same job split attention. So do twin examples or lookalike subplots.

Audit:

Example:

Nonfiction-specific trims

Readers want outcomes, not throat music.

Trim list:

Speed drills:


Use these cuts to clear brush. Voice and stakes rise when clutter falls. Trim with purpose, then read aloud. Clean prose rewards both writer and reader.

What to Keep, Protect, or Even Expand

Cutting is half the job. The other half is knowing what deserves guard duty. These are the pieces that carry weight. Trim around them, not through them.

Specific, concrete details

Specifics earn trust. Generalities waste space.

One sharp image often replaces a paragraph of fog.

Quick exercise, five minutes:

Voice, rhythm, and motifs

Voice separates your pages from everyone else’s. Protect phrasing choices, the pulse of your sentences, and any recurring lines that act like mile markers.

Make a note on your style sheet for slang, contractions, and pet constructions you want preserved. Tell future you, and your copyeditor, what stays.

Setups and payoffs

Readers love fairness. Promises made, promises kept. A planted detail in chapter two turns into a key in the finale. That cause for delight deserves protection.

Nonfiction version:

Before cutting a scene, make a quick ledger:

If removal breaks a chain, move the setup into a surviving scene, or rebuild a small bridge line.

Interiority and interpretation

Action shows what happened. Interiority tells readers what it meant. That link carries theme.

Fiction example:

Nonfiction example:

Rule of thumb:

Character choices and cause-and-effect

Readers track decisions and consequences. Protect beats where someone chooses, fails, or pays. Those beats form spine and stakes.

Cut the commute. Keep the choice and the ripple.

Nonfiction parallel:

Audit tip:

Nonfiction essentials

Promises to the reader outrank your research crush. Hold the backbone.

Speed check:

Orientation aids that speed comprehension

Readers forgive almost anything when they never feel lost. Anchors and signposts earn their keep.

Fiction anchors:

Nonfiction anchors:

If early readers ask “Where are we” or “Who is talking,” expand anchors. Not with fluff, with one precise line that locks context.

How to protect these during cuts

One last nudge. Sparse prose still carries flavor. Keep the flavor. Lose the water.

A Practical Decision Framework for Keep vs. Cut

Decision fatigue loves revision. Use a simple loop, use it every pass. Faster choices, stronger pages.

Tag the draft

Give every unit a job label. Five tags, no drama.

Quick examples.

Fiction:

Nonfiction:

Mark tags in the margin or with color. Red for Cut, green for Keep, yellow for Compress, blue for Combine, purple for Move. A rainbow of clarity.

Run the Two-Job Test

Every unit earns a place by doing at least two jobs. Options include:

Audit example, fiction:

Audit example, nonfiction:

Fail once, fix or delete. Fail twice, delete.

Build a quick reverse outline

Summarize each scene or section in a spreadsheet or a doc. One line per unit:

Now scan for duplicates and orphans. Two scenes where nothing changes, merge or remove. A section without outcome, rewrite or cut. If one beat appears three times with equal intensity, save the strongest version and prune the rest.

Tip: rate intensity from one to three. A three deserves space. A one likely joins a neighbor.

Weigh reader signals

Readers show you where attention drops. Track signals, translate to action.

One client note to steal: place a “speed bump” emoji at each skim point, a “map pin” at each confusion point. Fix those first. Momentum returns fast.

Check word-count norms and pacing

Right size supports reach and readability. Rough ranges help with scope:

If a draft sits far outside the range, target trims or expansions by section. Long slow opening, aim for one scene shorter. Bulky middle, remove a sub-plot or combine two examples. Thin ending, expand payoffs and consequence.

Pacing hint. Alternate long and short units. A run of dense pages begs for a quick scene or a tight list. Variety keeps eyes on the page.

Use a Cut Bin without regret

Separate file, simple rules. Title: Cut Bin, plus project name. Add date stamps. When you remove a chunk, paste it into the bin with a brief note:

This habit reduces fear. You are not burning work. You are moving words to a holding pen. Odds favor smarter reuse later.

Do an integrity check before you delete

Before removal, verify you will not snap a thread.

Bridge examples.

Fiction:

Nonfiction:

A short workflow you can repeat

The loop gives you clear steps. No hand-wringing, no drift. Keep the best. Remove the rest. Move forward with a lean, coherent draft worth your name.

Tightening Techniques That Preserve Voice

Tightening should make your voice cleaner, not smaller. Cut weight, keep personality. Here is how.

Combine low-stakes scenes into one

If two scenes aim for the same beat, merge them. Give the new scene a sharper objective, a real obstacle, and a clear turn.

Quick plan:

Fiction example:

Nonfiction example:

Mini exercise: list three nearby scenes or sections. If two aim at the same point, outline a single scene that does the job louder.

Convert backstory or exposition to on-page action

Readers learn faster when context rides on action. Drip the past in one line at the moment it changes a choice.

Fiction:

Nonfiction:

Rule of thumb: if a sentence explains motive, try one action plus one sharp line that reveals the same thing.

Replace nominalizations and weak passives

Nominalizations turn verbs into fluffy nouns. Passive voice buries the actor. Shift to concrete subjects and active verbs when clarity needs it.

Quick test: ask, who did what, to whom, when. Put that order on the page.

Compress wordy constructions

Shave the padding. Try these swaps during a line edit.

One pass, one search list, big results.

Swap adverb–verb pairs for precise verbs

Pick a stronger verb, lose the helper.

Save adverbs for surprise or tone. If the verb does the job alone, let it.

Trade general description for one telling detail

Generic description fades. One concrete detail sticks and signals voice.

Fiction:

Nonfiction:

Pick the detail that reveals character, stakes, or authority. Keep it. Remove the rest.

Compress nonfiction without losing authority

Trim with structure, not apology.

Quote example:

Run targeted Find and Replace sweeps

Do focused passes. Do not fix everything at once.

Hedges and filler:

Filters:

Expletive openings:

Wordy starters:

Echo words:

Mechanics:

Keep a checklist. Run it near the end, when you will not break structure.

Read aloud to protect cadence

Your ear protects voice. Read the pages aloud, or use text-to-speech at a slow speed.

Listening checklist:

If you keep fragments, dialect, or a quirky construction, note that decision in a style note. Future you, and your copyeditor, will thank you.

A quick drill to practice

Pick one page. Set a five-minute timer.

Small wins stack up. Tight pages, strong voice, cleaner book.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Two‑Job Test and how do I apply it when deciding what to cut?

The Two‑Job Test means every paragraph, scene or section should perform at least two functions (for example: move plot and reveal character, or clarify an argument and provide a practical takeaway). Highlight a unit, write two purposes beside it, and if you struggle to name two, either strengthen the unit so it earns its place or move it to the Cut Bin.

Use this test as a trimming heuristic across fiction and nonfiction: it speeds decisions and prevents random deletions that break setups and payoffs.

How do I build a reverse outline that actually helps with cuts and restructuring?

Make a fresh document and list every scene or section in order, adding one‑line notes for purpose, outcome, POV/topic, setting and word count. That one‑line-per-unit approach exposes duplicates, orphans and weak links quickly and lets you see where beats cluster or vanish across the arc or argument.

Do a reverse outline whenever you suspect pacing issues or before a major prune: it’s a fast, reliable way to plan merges, moves and targeted cuts without guessing.

What belongs in my style sheet and when should I update it?

Include names and spellings, place names, hyphenation rules, numbers and date conventions, dialogue conventions, world rules, recurring terms, voice notes and the reference sources you follow (Chicago, Merriam‑Webster, New Oxford, etc.).

Update the style sheet every time you make a rule decision during revision so copyeditors and proofreaders can enforce consistency; treat it as a living file you consult on every pass.

How should I set up and use a Cut Bin so I can delete without panic?

Create a separate document titled Cut Bin + project name, add dated headers by chapter, and paste removed chunks under their original location with a one‑line reason and page number. That preserves work for reuse (bonus scenes, newsletters, appendices) and removes psychological friction from deleting.

Before you paste a cut, run a quick integrity check for setups and payoffs: if deletion breaks a chain, move the setup line into a surviving scene or add a bridge rather than keeping the dead weight.

Which high‑value cuts give the fastest improvements in most drafts?

Fast wins come from removing throat‑clearing openings, scenes or sections that show no change, long info‑dumps, redundant passages, filler and hedging language, weak modifiers and small‑talk dialogue. These trims raise pace and make the remaining stakes read louder.

Run short, focused sweeps — search for your favourite crutch words and -ly adverbs, test scene entry/exit states, and delete or compress before you polish lines; you’ll see momentum return quickly.

How can I tighten prose without flattening my voice, rhythm or motifs?

Use tightening techniques that preserve personality: combine low‑stakes scenes into one sharper scene, convert backstory into on‑page action, replace nominalisations and adverb–verb pairs with precise verbs, and trade general description for a single telling detail. Keep motifs and recurring phrasing by marking them on your style sheet so they survive cuts.

Always read aloud or use text‑to‑speech after tightening; your ear flags where cadence or voice has been unintentionally sanded off.

What quick decision framework stops fatigue and keeps revision moving?

Tag every unit with one of five labels — Keep, Cut, Compress, Combine, Move — then apply the Two‑Job Test and consult your reverse outline. Use measurable goals (trim X% this week, shorten openings by one scene) and track reader signals (skims, confusion, boredom) to prioritise fixes.

Work in short focused sessions, log each change in a simple change log, and run an integrity check before any final deletion to ensure setups, payoffs and timeline links remain intact.

Writing Manual Cover

Download FREE ebook

Claim your free eBook today and join over 25,000 writers who have read and benefited from this ebook.

'It is probably one of the best books on writing I've read so far.' Miz Bent

Get free book