what is book editing

What Is Book Editing

What Book Editing Covers and Why It Matters

Editing turns a draft into a book readers trust. Not by sprinkling commas, by shaping purpose, structure, and voice so the whole thing holds.

Here is the heart of it. A professional editor refines your manuscript for clarity, coherence, voice, and market readiness. The goal is a book that lands with the reader you want, fits its shelf, and earns attention from agents, publishers, or a savvy indie audience.

What editing touches

You get an editorial letter that explains what works and what drags, an annotated manuscript with comments and suggestions, and a path to revise with purpose.

Why readers feel the difference

Editing improves the reading experience. It trims confusion. It strengthens momentum. It raises credibility.

A quick before-and-after to show the shift.

Same word count, more purpose, higher stakes, cleaner beats.

Plain, specific, useful. Readers lean in when you respect their time.

Editing is not proofreading

Editing addresses content and craft, from big picture to sentence level. Proofreading is the last cold pass on designed pages. One shapes the book. The other hunts surface errors before print or upload.

Think of the difference like this:

You need both, but not in the same week.

Where editing sits in the publishing path

Draft and redraft. Share with a few target beta readers. Then hire the right level of edit. After revisions, move to copyediting. Next comes typesetting or ebook formatting. Proofread on pages. Then distribute.

Skipping steps invites rework. Moving a chapter after line editing costs money and peace.

Quick exercise to set your aim

Editors do their best work when the brief is clear. Set the guardrails now.

Write three sentences.

  1. Target reader: “This book serves __________, who want __________.”
  2. Lane or genre: “The book sits with __________, and follows the expectations of that shelf.”
  3. Goal: “My plan is to __________, so the edit needs to prepare for __________.”

Examples:

Share these lines with your editor. They shape the level of edit and the timeline.

What you gain

Good editing is a partnership. Bring a clear aim, an open mind, and a draft worth pushing. Your readers will feel the work on page one.

Types of Book Editing (From Big-Picture to Final Polish)

Think of editing as a zoom lens. Start wide. Tighten focus. Finish with a polish so clean no one trips on a typo.

Manuscript assessment

A manuscript assessment is a diagnostic report. No edits in the file, no Track Changes. You receive a clear read on strengths, risks, and priorities for revision.

Typical contents:

Good for early drafts and for writers who want a map before ripping up chapters.

Quick example:

You revise with purpose, then move to heavier editing.

Developmental or substantive editing

This is the macro pass. The work happens at the level of story or argument. Structure. Stakes. Order. Chapter goals.

What a dev edit addresses:

Typical deliverables:

Micro example, fiction:

Micro example, nonfiction:

A solid dev pass pays for itself, because the later stages move faster.

Line editing

Line editing works at sentence and paragraph level. The goal is clarity, tone, rhythm, and flow while protecting your voice.

What shifts here:

Tiny before and after, fiction:

Tiny before and after, nonfiction:

Line editing often includes light recasts to show you the stronger choice, then you apply the pattern across the book.

Copyediting

Copyediting deals with correctness and consistency. The prose stays yours. The grammar stops wobbling.

Scope:

Examples of decisions recorded on a style sheet:

Copyediting also catches subtle landmines. “Principle” versus “principal.” “Year-over-year,” not “year over year” if the sheet says so.

Proofreading

Proofreading is the last stop before print or upload. The text is laid out. The job is to catch surface errors and layout problems.

What proofreaders look for:

Example:

Do not add new paragraphs here. Changes at proof stage risk new errors.

Adjacent services

Some books need extra expertise. Bring it in early.

These services protect you, your readers, and your book’s reception.

Avoid expensive rework

Order matters. Freeze structure before line or copyediting. Lock wording before proofreading.

A practical sequence:

  1. Manuscript assessment if you need direction.
  2. Developmental edit and your revisions.
  3. Line edit and your revisions.
  4. Copyedit and your revisions.
  5. Layout for print and ebook.
  6. Proofread on designed pages.

Two quick checks to keep you on track:

Hold the line. Your future self, and your budget, will thank you.

The Editing Process and Typical Deliverables

You move from diagnosis to polish. Each pass serves a single job. Skip a step, problems linger and cost money.

Workflow, step by step

  1. Manuscript assessment, optional. A high-level read with no line edits. You receive a report on strengths and risks.
  2. Developmental or substantive edit. Structure, plot or argument, pacing, order. Big decisions live here.
  3. Line edit. Tone, rhythm, clarity at sentence and paragraph level. Voice stays intact.
  4. Copyedit. Grammar, usage, consistency, and a written record of choices.
  5. Typesetting and ebook formatting. Words meet design.
  6. Proofreading on designed pages. Final safety check before print or upload.

A quick rule. Move big blocks before step 3. Lock wording before step 6.

What you receive from an editor

Sample style choices:

Save the style sheet. Share with designers, proofreaders, and future collaborators.

Mapping tools that keep a book coherent

For fiction:

For nonfiction:

Mini exercise, twenty minutes:

Tools and standards the industry trusts

Simple naming scheme:

Never overwrite old files. Store in a single folder with dates.

Timelines and round rhythm

Expect multiple rounds. Editing is revision, feedback, revision again. Build space for your own work between passes.

Common ranges for an 80,000-word book:

Rush requests raise cost and risk. A steady schedule lowers stress and error rates.

Project management that saves sanity

Before work starts, agree on:

Use a change log to track decisions.

Suggested columns:

Two sample entries:

A short log prevents whiplash, especially during late changes.

A tiny walkthrough

Thriller example:

Same path, fewer headaches, better book.

How to Choose the Right Book Editor and Budget Wisely

You want an editor who makes the book stronger without flattening your voice. Start with fit, then lock down scope and money. A steady process beats guesswork.

Start with fit, not price

Quick test:

Use a sample edit to test chemistry

Request a one to two page sample on a representative passage. Middle-of-the-pack pages work best, not your best paragraph and not a messy outtake.

What to look for:

Avoid excerpts with heavy worldbuilding jargon or unique formatting for this test. Aim for typical prose instead of outliers.

Simple request template:

Subject: Sample edit request for [Title], 82k thriller

Hello [Name],

I’m seeking a [developmental edit | line edit | copyedit] for an 82,000-word thriller aimed at readers of Lee Child and Tana French. Goal, query to agents in August.

Would you complete a one-page sample on the attached chapter 6 excerpt? I’m looking to assess voice protection, clarity of comments, and fit. If available, please share recent projects in this genre and a typical timeline.

Thanks,
[Your Name]

Nail the contract before anyone starts

A clear agreement protects both sides. Insist on:

Ask which style guide the editor uses. Chicago Manual of Style for books is common, with Merriam-Webster or Oxford for spelling.

Understand pricing without guesswork

Editors price by word, by hour, or by project. Complexity, heavy research, references, and rush timelines raise cost.

Typical ranges in USD, not promises, a starting lens:

Example budgets for an 80,000-word novel:

Rush fees often add 25 to 50 percent. Multiple rounds extend timelines and budgets. Plan breathing room between passes.

Money-saving moves that protect quality:

Red flags worth walking away from

A clean way to shortlist

Pick three editors. Send the same request and the same pages. Compare side by side.

Score each on:

Choose the editor who asks smart questions about reader needs, outcome, and success measures. Look for questions about your comps, positioning, and schedule. Curiosity signals care.

A tiny case study

A memoir writer hired a line editor before fixing structure. Beautiful sentences, weak arc. Money spent, revision still ahead. Round two, a developmental edit reshaped chapters, tightened the throughline, and cut three digressions. Later line and copy passes finished the job with half the churn. Same budget overall, far less pain.

Final checklist

Pick for fit, plan for stages, guard your voice. Your future readers will feel the difference.

Preparing Your Manuscript for Editing (Self-Edit Checklist)

Editors do their best work with a clean, coherent draft. You save money, shorten timelines, and protect your voice when you prep first. Think of this as sharpening the blade before the cut.

Structural readiness

Get the bones in order before anyone fusses with sentences.

Mini-exercise, 20 minutes:

Voice and clarity

Your voice should feel consistent and confident. Help readers stay with you.

Consistency and accuracy

Build a simple style sheet. Editors love one. You will too.

Include:

Now verify high-risk details:

Formatting basics

Make the file easy to read and edit.

Smart tools, smart limits

Use tools for consistency, not for voice decisions.

Quick setup:

Beta readers who help, not derail

Bring in two or three readers from your target audience. No partners, no parents. You want informed reactions, not approval.

Give a short brief:

Offer focused questions:

Collect notes, then look for patterns. One outlier is opinion. Two or more readers flagging the same spot signals a fix. Make those changes first.

Quick pre-edit checklist

Do this prep and your editor walks into a tidy kitchen. More time on substance, less on crumbs. Your future readers feel that care on every page.

Advanced Considerations for Publishing Success

You have a solid draft. Now think like a publisher. Decisions here shape the reading experience, print files, and launch.

Two paths, two plans

Traditional route:

Independent route:

Quick test:

Production handoffs and page proofs

Once layout is complete, you review designed pages. This is a different skill from editing in Word. You are checking how words live on a page.

What to scan, page by page:

Fifteen-minute drill:

Nonfiction extras

Nonfiction brings extra parts. Handle them early to avoid legal or production snags.

Permissions:

References:

Indexing:

Figures and tables:

Inclusivity and risk

Your words land in the real world. Bring in expert eyes when stakes are high.

Sensitivity reading:

Light fact-checking:

Memoir and narrative risk:

Metadata and launch

Metadata sells your book while you sleep. Tidy metadata, stronger reach.

Lock these elements:

Simple back-cover formula:

ARCs and early reviews:

Two quick exercises:

Actionable timeline and file hygiene

Protect the finish line. Small habits here prevent expensive do-overs.

This is the work readers never see, yet they feel every decision. Smooth pages. Clean claims. A promise kept from cover to last line.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is structural (substantive) editing and how does it differ from other editing stages?

Structural or substantive editing works at the book level: plot/argument, scene order, pacing, point of view and the throughline from first page to last. Deliverables are usually an editorial letter, inline queries, a scene map or reverse outline and a preliminary style sheet.

It sits before line editing, copyediting and proofreading — freeze structure first, then tune sentences, then correct grammar and continuity, and finally proofread on designed pages to catch layout issues.

What should I include in my one‑page brief or submission package?

Share a one‑sentence premise, a one‑page synopsis or thesis, three–five comp titles with notes, a chapter/scene list (POV, location, purpose, change), a simple timeline and a short character bible or evidence log for nonfiction. Add any red lines and your chosen spelling/style guide.

Send a tidy Word .docx, the decision log and a living style sheet up front — editors use these tools to reduce queries and keep consistency across the structural pass.

What will I receive from a structural edit and what will it not include?

Expect a 5–12 page editorial letter that names the book’s promise and ranked fixes, an annotated manuscript with Track Changes and queries, a scene or beat map, and a starter style sheet. You may also get sample rewrites to model tone or transitions.

Structural edits do not typically include full copyediting, proofreading on designed pages, permissions, or comprehensive fact‑checking — those are adjacent services to commission separately or after the macro pass.

How should I self‑revise before hiring an editor to save time and money?

Do a targeted prep: write a one‑sentence premise, make a scene or chapter list (goal, conflict, outcome), complete a POV pass to stop head‑hopping, trim obvious filler and repeated beats, and run tool checks for filter words and adverbs. Fix high‑risk continuity items like names and timelines.

Bring two to three beta readers for pattern feedback, tidy the manuscript into standard format and start a simple style sheet so your editor focuses on structural work rather than surface clean‑up.

How long does a structural edit take and how do I build a realistic timeline?

Timelines vary with length and complexity; a typical structural pass for a novel can take two to four weeks for the editor, plus a two‑to‑four‑week author revision window. For an 80k manuscript plan mapping in week one, delivery of the letter and annotated file in week four, and 2–4 weeks for your revisions.

Book backwards from your launch, include buffer weeks between passes, and lock structure before commissioning line editing to avoid costly rework.

What macro techniques do editors use to find gaps, pacing problems and POV leaks?

Editors use reverse outlines, scene maps, beat maps and card sorts to visualise structure. They label units S (scene) or Q (sequel), check the stakes ladder across quarter marks, and run a goal‑conflict‑outcome test on each scene to spot stagnation or unnecessary repeats.

These techniques quickly expose missing setups, sagging midpoints, misplaced reveals and POV slippage so fixes are prioritised and surgical rather than guesswork.

How do I choose the right editor and agree scope and budget without surprises?

Shortlist editors by genre fit, ask for a one‑ to two‑page sample edit on a mid‑manuscript passage and compare how well they preserve voice and explain changes. Insist on a written contract that states level of edit, deliverables (editorial letter, annotated file, map), number of passes, timeline and payment schedule.

Understand pricing models (per word, per hour, or project), expect developmental edits to cost more than line edits, and watch for red flags: no sample edit, vague scope or promises of guaranteed success.

Writing Manual Cover

Download FREE ebook

Claim your free eBook today and join over 25,000 writers who have read and benefited from this ebook.

'It is probably one of the best books on writing I've read so far.' Miz Bent

Get free book