The Difference Between Self Publishing And Traditional Publishing

Gary Smailes | 29 December 2025

What Each Path Really Means

You have two publishing jobs in front of you. Hire a team through a publisher. Or become the publisher. Same book, different work.

Traditional publishing, in practice

• You research and query literary agents. An agent offers representation, then submits to editors at publishers.
• A publisher acquires your book for specific formats and territories. You sign a contract and receive an advance against royalties.
• Their team handles editorial rounds, cover design, copyediting, proofreading, typesetting, printing, and distribution to retailers and libraries.
• You still market, but a publicist supports launch windows. Sales reps pitch to bookstores.

A quick sketch of time. Say you sign in March. Developmental edit in spring. Copyedit in summer. Cover meeting by August. Bound galleys in autumn. Publication the following fall. Twelve to twenty-four months from deal to shelf, depending on list space and production calendars.

What you give up. Scheduling power, cover veto in many cases, pricing control, and some rights for an agreed term. What you gain. A professional crew, retail reach, and a shot at co-op placement and reviews that favor publisher submissions.

Self-publishing, in practice

• You hire your own editors, cover designer, formatter, and sensitivity readers if needed.
• You set specs. Trim size, paper color, typography, front matter, back matter, EPUB files.
• You purchase ISBNs for full imprint control. You upload to Amazon KDP for Amazon, then IngramSpark for bookstores and libraries.
• You manage metadata. Categories, keywords, BISAC codes, series data, product descriptions.
• You plan and run marketing. ARC team, newsletter, ads, price promotions, retailer page audits.

A quick sketch of time. Hire a dev editor in May. Revise in June. Copyedit in July. Cover concepts in parallel. Proofreading in August. Upload in September. One to six months once the manuscript is stable, since you own the calendar.

What you give up. A publisher’s sales team, advances, and automatic bookstore placement. What you gain. Creative control, pricing control, faster decisions, higher royalty share per book.

Control, gatekeeping, and workload

Traditional offers access and polish, with a door person at every stage. Agents choose lists. Editors choose slots. Stores stock what reps sell. Fewer tasks for you, fewer levers too.

Self removes those doors. Every lever moves when you pull it. You set cover direction, price, and release date. You also own the project plan, vendor selection, quality control, and budgets. Freedom plus logistics. If you enjoy building teams and making decisions, this suits you. If you prefer to focus on drafts and revisions while a house runs production, traditional fits.

Speed to market

• Traditional timelines run long. A publisher builds seasonal lists, prints galleys, gathers preorders, and schedules far ahead. Expect a year or two after the deal.
• Self timelines run short. Once files are final, uploads and approvals move in days. Retail pages go live within hours to a week. Print proofs add a small delay.

Faster is not always smarter. Editing depth, beta reads, and design time still matter. Rushing hurts both paths.

Rights ownership

Traditional deals license publishing rights for specific formats, languages, territories, and a term tied to sales. Subsidiary rights might include audio, film, and foreign. You receive royalties per contract once the advance earns out.

Self means you keep all rights by default. You decide whether to license audio, foreign, or film. You decide pricing and edition changes. You decide when a book returns to development for a new cover or edit.

Ask two questions before signing anything. Which rights are you granting, and for how long. What triggers rights reversion.

A quick reality check

Both paths expect author effort. Traditional expects you to build a platform, write guest pieces, show up for interviews, and keep writing the next book. Self expects the same, plus vendor wrangling and ongoing metadata work. Pick your work, not a fantasy.

Actionable: list your non-negotiables

Grab ten minutes. Write answers, not wishes.

• Creative control. Covers, pricing, format, edits. Where do you refuse to bend.
• Timeline. Do you need release within six to nine months, or are you happy to wait for a seasonal slot.
• Bookstore presence. Do you want a shot at front tables and library orders through a publisher’s sales reps.
• Advance. Do you need upfront money, or are you comfortable investing now for royalties later.
• Workload. Do you enjoy hiring and managing freelancers. Do you want a house to run production.

Circle the top two. Those guide your path more than any blog post.

Actionable: starting steps for a traditional route

Build a sharp submission package.

• Query letter. One paragraph on the hook and stakes. One on the book’s key specs, genre, and word count. One on bio and comps. Polite, lean, professional.
• Synopsis. One to two pages, present tense, full plot including the ending.
• Sample pages. Follow each agent’s guidelines. Usually first 10 pages or first three chapters.

Research, then track.

• Use MSWL and agency sites to match taste and genre.
• Use QueryTracker to log submissions, dates, and responses.
• Note publisher imprints open to unagented work if your category fits, then follow their guidelines with care.

Send in batches. Iterate based on response patterns. Keep writing while you wait. Patience pays here.

A short snapshot to close

Two mornings. Traditional. Your inbox holds line edits from a copyeditor, a cover concept, and a note from your publicist about galley requests. You focus on revisions. You answer questions. You plan launch tasks inside the publisher’s schedule.

Self. Your inbox holds a dev edit memo, three cover mockups, a proof PDF from your formatter, and a print quote. You approve art, log metadata, order proofs, brief your ARC team, and schedule ads. You set the release date. You own the levers.

Neither path is lesser. Each is a business choice. Choose with eyes open, a plan on paper, and a book you believe in.

Money, Royalties, and Rights

Publishing runs on two engines. Cash now. Cash later. Know which one you are choosing.

Advances, and how they pay out

An advance is money upfront against future royalties. Ranges hover around 1,000 to 50,000 dollars or pounds for most debuts. Some genres and big platforms land higher.

Payments arrive in pieces. A common split looks like this:

• On signing.
• On delivery and acceptance of the final manuscript.
• On publication.
• Sometimes on paperback publication.

Example. A 20,000 advance paid in four equal parts means 5,000 at each milestone.

Earning out means your royalties from sales equal the advance already paid. After that point, new royalties flow to you. Before that point, statements show sales, but checks only cover scheduled advance instalments.

Royalty math in traditional deals

Rates vary by format and contract language. Typical numbers:

• Hardcover, 10 to 15 percent of list price.
• Trade paperback, about 7.5 to 8 percent of list.
• Ebook, 25 percent of net receipts.
• Audiobook, often 25 percent of net.

Net receipts means what the publisher receives from the retailer. For ebooks on Amazon, the retailer keeps 30 percent of list in many cases, the publisher keeps 70 percent. Your share is 25 percent of that 70 percent. So roughly 17.5 percent of list.

Numbers help. Use these quick snapshots:

• Hardcover listed at 28 dollars, 10 percent rate. You earn 2.80 per copy. At 15 percent, 4.20 per copy.
• Trade paperback at 16 dollars, 8 percent rate. You earn 1.28 per copy.
• Ebook at 4.99 dollars, retailer pays publisher about 3.49 before delivery fees. You earn about 0.87 per copy at 25 percent of net.
• Audiobook with net to publisher of 10 dollars. You earn 2.50 per unit.

Statements usually arrive twice a year. Reserves against returns reduce early payments on print formats. Expect a lag.

Self‑publishing revenue, real numbers

Ebooks on KDP pay either 70 percent or 35 percent of list. The 70 percent tier applies in eligible territories and price bands. KDP subtracts a small delivery fee per megabyte for the 70 percent tier.

Print on KDP pays 60 percent of list, then subtracts print cost. Expanded distribution through KDP pays about 40 percent of list, then subtracts print cost.

IngramSpark pays after a wholesale discount you set, often 50 to 55 percent, then subtracts print cost. In return, bookstores and libraries view your title through their usual channels.

Snapshots:

• Ebook at 4.99 dollars, 70 percent tier, 1 MB file. Delivery fee roughly 0.10. Payout about 3.39 per sale.
• KDP Print, 14.99 trade paperback, black and white, 300 pages. 60 percent of list is 8.99. Print cost around 3.60. Payout about 5.39 per sale on Amazon.
• IngramSpark, same book, 55 percent discount. Ingram pays 45 percent of list, so 6.75. Print cost 4.20. Payout about 2.55 per sale through bookstores.

Those print costs shift with page count, ink, trim size, and territory. Check calculators before you price.

Upfront costs you budget for in self‑publishing

Typical ranges for an 80,000‑word book:

• Developmental editing, 1,500 to 4,000 dollars or more.
• Copyediting, 800 to 2,000.
• Proofreading, 500 to 1,200.
• Cover design, 300 for a solid premade, up to 2,500 for custom or illustrated.
• Interior formatting for EPUB and print, 150 to 600.
• Audiobook narration, 200 to 400 per finished hour, or a royalty share deal.

You choose vendors. You schedule passes. Quality rises with multiple rounds and a good brief.

Cash flow and taxes

Traditional brings money early, spread over months or years. Royalties, if due after earn out, arrive on a semiannual schedule. Plan for a long tail.

Self‑publishing requires investment before launch. Retailers pay monthly or quarterly after a delay. KDP pays about 60 days after month end. IngramSpark pays on a similar lag. Set aside tax from receipts. If you sell direct, track sales tax or VAT where rules apply. Speak with an accountant who knows publishing.

Rights and clauses that deserve a slow read

You trade money for permission to exploit rights. Read for scope and exits.

• Territory. World rights or specific regions. English only, or all languages.
• Formats. Print, ebook, audio, large print, merchandise. Keep what you plan to develop yourself.
• Subsidiary rights. Audio, film or TV, foreign. Who controls them. What split applies. Does the publisher have a plan to exploit.
• Non‑compete. Clear limits on overlap with your next book. Define subject, audience, and timeline.
• Option clause. Narrow and time‑boxed. The house wants a first look at your next work, not lifelong control of your career.
• Out‑of‑print definition. Tie it to sales or availability across formats, not only “available in any edition.” Include a clear reversion trigger.
• Term and reversion. When do rights return to you. What notices are required. What deadlines bind both parties.
• Audit clause. You have the right to review royalty statements and underlying records.

Keep PDFs of every version. Track dates. When a clause feels vague, ask for examples and add language.

Build a simple P&L

You need a back‑of‑the‑envelope view before you set a price or an ad budget. Do this on paper.

1. Pick a price. Example, 4.99 ebook and 14.99 paperback.
2. Estimate royalty per unit using the snapshots above.
3. Note fixed costs. Editing, design, formatting. Example, 3,500 total.
4. Note variable costs per unit. Print cost for paperbacks. Ad spend per sale if you plan paid traffic.
5. Break‑even units = fixed costs divided by per‑unit profit.

Two quick runs:

• Ebook only. Payout per sale 3.39. No per‑unit cost beyond ads. If you spend 0.60 per sale on ads, profit per unit 2.79. Break even at about 1,255 copies on a 3,500 budget.
• Paperback only on KDP. Payout 5.39. No ads for this run. Break even at about 650 copies on a 3,500 budget.

Reality sits between formats, with mixed sales and some ads. Update the sheet after launch, then adjust prices or spend.

Mini‑exercise. Fill these blanks for your book: Price, royalty per unit, print cost, planned ad spend per unit, total fixed costs. Compute break‑even units for each format. Post the numbers above your desk.

Get expert eyes, and own your ISBNs

Ask a publishing attorney to review any contract before you sign. If budget bites, join the Authors Guild in the US or the Society of Authors in the UK for guidance. A small fee now, fewer headaches later.

Buy your own ISBNs through Bowker in the US or Nielsen in the UK. You control the publisher of record name and your metadata. That control matters when you move distributors or run special editions.

Money, royalties, rights. Learn the terms, run the math, and choose the mix that fits your goals and your stomach. The numbers will keep you honest.

Editing, Production, and Distribution

Books are made in the middle. Editing, design, files, and how the book moves through the world. Get this stretch right, and your odds improve everywhere else.

Editing, the work behind the words

Traditional houses manage the editorial stack. A development editor shapes the book. A copyeditor checks clarity, consistency, and grammar. A proofreader catches the last grit before press. They use house style sheets so every comma and character name stays consistent.

Self‑publishing asks you to hire the team and set the order of play. Common sequence:

1. Developmental edit. Big picture structure, stakes, gaps.
2. Line or stylistic edit if prose needs smoothing.
3. Copyedit for usage, continuity, and fact checks.
4. Proofread on designed pages, not the Word file.
5. Sensitivity reads where relevant. Do this before proof.

Give each stage a clear brief. Tell the editor the genre, audience, comps, and your goals. If you hate slow openings and love tight dialogue, say so. Ask for a style sheet. Keep it updated.

A style sheet lists:

• Names, places, timeline, invented terms.
• Hyphenation and capitalization choices. Email or e‑mail, that sort of thing.
• Numbers and dates, your chosen dictionary, any exceptions.
• Voice notes. Formal tone, slang limits, pet words to watch.

Mini‑exercise. Open a fresh doc. Create four headings, Characters, Places, Style decisions, Timeline. Fill each with five entries. Share it with every editor and designer.

Design and formatting, what readers feel before page one

Traditional gives you a cover and a typeset interior built to house standards. You give feedback, within reason. Series branding gets handled.

In self‑publishing, you are the art director. Hire a cover designer with credits in your genre. Give a tight brief:

• Title, subtitle, author name, series info.
• Genre and audience.
• Five comp covers you like, and why.
• One line summary of tone. Dark heist. Cozy small town mystery. Upmarket family drama.
• Non‑negotiables. Author photo on back. Room for award seals later.

For the interior, reflowable EPUB for ebooks and a print‑ready PDF for paperbacks and hardcovers. Tools like Vellum, Atticus, or Affinity Publisher work. If you DIY, use strong templates and learn widows and orphans, scene break spacing, and how to build a linked table of contents. Keep fonts readable. No novelty type for body text.

Quick interior checks:

• First lines after scene breaks not indented.
• Chapter openers sit on right‑hand pages in print unless series convention differs.
• No stacked hyphens or rivers of white space.
• Running heads and folios correct and consistent.

ISBN and imprint, who owns the plate on the door

Traditional assigns its own ISBNs. You publish under their imprint.

Self‑publishing, buy ISBNs through Bowker in the US or Nielsen in the UK. Do not rely on free platform identifiers if you want control. Owning ISBNs lets you:

• Choose an imprint name.
• Control metadata across vendors.
• Move printers without changing the product identity.

Register your imprint with consistent contact info and a domain. This is your publisher record.

Files and specs, the boring stuff that saves reprints

Standard formats:

• EPUB for ebooks. Use EPUB 3 with embedded fonts cleared for commercial use.
• Print‑ready PDF for interiors and covers.

Decide trim size early. Common fiction trims are 5 x 8, 5.25 x 8, and 6 x 9 inches. Nonfiction often leans larger. Confirm margins with the printer’s template. Build bleeds for any full‑bleed elements.

Covers need front, spine, and back in one PDF. Spine width depends on page count and paper stock. Use the printer’s calculator. Work in CMYK for print, RGB for ebook images. Keep black text as 100 percent K, not rich black. Export at 300 dpi for print and keep file sizes modest for ebooks.

Sanity checklist before upload:

• EPUB validates with no errors.
• Interior PDF has fonts embedded.
• Cover PDF matches trim and spine specs.
• Barcode placed or left to the printer as required.
• Accessibility basics set, alt text for images in EPUB, logical heading order, language tag.

Printing options, POD first, offset when demand is real

Print on demand keeps risk low. The usual setup is this:

• KDP Print for Amazon. Choose standard color or black and white, set price, pick territories.
• IngramSpark for bookstores and libraries. Set a wholesale discount, often 50 to 55 percent. Decide on returns. Returnable increases bookstore comfort, but you shoulder the risk.

Avoid KDP’s expanded distribution if you plan to use IngramSpark. Let Ingram feed the wider market. Price the same across vendors.

Offset printing makes sense only when you have firm orders, live events, or a stash of direct sales ready to go. Offset lowers per‑unit cost at volume, but adds freight, storage, and cash tied up in cartons. Order printer proofs before greenlighting a run.

Distribution, how your book reaches hands

Traditional houses have sales reps who pitch to chains, indies, wholesalers, and library vendors. Your book lives in seasonal catalogs. Co‑op can put you on front tables. Library marketing runs on relationships and data feeds.

Self‑publishing means you build reach through platforms and hustle. KDP covers every Amazon store. IngramSpark lists your title with Ingram, which feeds bookstores and libraries. That does not guarantee shelf space. For indie stores, send a short, respectful pitch.

Simple pitch outline:

• One line description, title, genre, hook.
• Local connection or reason their readers will care.
• Availability through Ingram, discount and return status.
• ISBN, price, trim, cover attached.
• Offer to sign stock or do an event. Keep the ask small.

Libraries order through Ingram or Baker & Taylor. Some accept patron requests, so prompt your newsletter to request your title.

Build a real production schedule

Deadlines keep quality high. Map yours with buffers.

Sample timeline for a novel:

• Week 1, hand manuscript to development editor.
• Week 4, revise.
• Week 6, line edit.
• Week 8, copyedit.
• Week 9, cover briefing and concept round starts.
• Week 10, interior layout from clean copyedited file.
• Week 11, proofread on designed pages.
• Week 12, author proof fixes and second proof check.
• Week 13, order print proof. Fix any issues. Lock files.
• Week 14, upload EPUB and print files. Set publication date 4 to 6 weeks out if you want preorders and ARCs.

Share a living style sheet with every vendor. Use one filename convention for all assets. Title_Format_Trim_Version_Date.pdf saves swearing later.

Mini‑exercise. Open your calendar. Block these four anchors, ARC send date, upload date, publication date, post‑launch check‑in at day 30. Work backward to fill the gaps.

Set up KDP and IngramSpark the smart way

• Create publisher accounts with your imprint name. Add tax and bank info early.
• Enter the same metadata on both platforms. Title, subtitle, author name, series name and number, description, BISAC codes, keywords, age range if relevant.
• Upload the same ISBN for the same format on both. Ebook has its own ISBN in some regions. Print formats each need their own.
• On KDP Print, select Amazon only for distribution if you plan to use IngramSpark for wider reach.
• On IngramSpark, choose a bookstore‑friendly discount and decide on returns with intent. Start with returnable to sender if you can handle freight on returns.

Before you go live, order a print proof from each printer. Hold them side by side. Check color, spine alignment, paper feel, and how the book opens. Fix the files, then flip the switch.

Production is not glamorous. It is the work that turns a manuscript into a book readers trust. Give this stage your full attention, and the rest of your plan stands taller.

Marketing, Publicity, and Discoverability

Books do not sell themselves. Both paths expect author hustle. Traditional houses bring a publicist who works hardest for 6 to 12 weeks around launch. Self‑publishing leans on work that keeps rolling for months and years. Different gears, same goal, readers.

What marketing looks like on each path

Traditional:

• Publicist handles press lists, trade outreach, blogger tours, and bookstore pitches.
• You show up for interviews, events, and features.
• Strong window near launch, then a taper unless awards, media, or word of mouth extend the arc.

Self‑publishing:

• You build an engine. Newsletter growth, retailer pages, pricing strategy, ads, and promotions.
• Slow, steady work brings compounding gains.
• Series and backlist carry most revenue over time.

Ask this before launch. Who needs to hear from you each week, and what do they need to hear?

Platform and brand, foundations first

Start early. Do not wait for a cover reveal.

Minimum platform setup:

• Simple website with bio, book page, and a sign‑up form.
• Email service with a welcome sequence. Deliver a reader magnet or first‑chapter sample.
• Social presence where your readers hang out. One or two places only. Consistent cover style and bio text across profiles.
• Retailer pages claimed on Amazon Author Central, Goodreads, and BookBub.

Brand basics:

• Consistent genre signals on covers and in blurbs.
• One line promise for readers. Example, “Twisty small‑town thrillers with sharp dialogue.” Use this everywhere.

Mini‑exercise. Write three emails now. Welcome, cover reveal, launch day. Save as templates.

Metadata, small levers that move sales

Retailers index data, then match readers to books. Help the match.

Checklist:

• Title and subtitle with clear hooks. Use strong nouns and verbs. Avoid puns unless genre expects them.
• Series data consistent across formats. Same numbering.
• BISAC codes, choose three that fit. One broad, two specific.
• Keywords, seven phrases readers use. Think problem, trope, setting, or vibe. Example for cozy mystery, “baking mystery,” “amateur sleuth,” “English village.”
• Product description that opens with a bold promise, then four punchy bullets or a short paragraph on stakes, then social proof if available.

Example opener:

“Her muffins never fail. Her alibis do. When a body turns up behind the tea shop, Nora must solve the case before the Harvest Fair opens.”

Update metadata after early reviews arrive. Add strong pull quotes near the top.

Reviews and ARCs, early proof for readers and retailers

Traditional houses send galleys to trade reviewers, booksellers, and librarians. Timing matters. Four months lead time wins more looks.

Self‑publishing uses a different mix:

• ARC team drawn from your newsletter and genre groups.
• NetGalley via a co‑op, BookSirens, or BlogTour services.
• Influencer outreach with a short pitch and a clean one‑page sheet.

ARC basics:

• Send digital files in EPUB and PDF. Watermark if needed.
• Include a polite request with links to retailer pages and Goodreads.
• Set a deadline two weeks before launch, then send a reminder three days before.

Never pay for a review. Do offer early access, signed copies, or behind‑the‑scenes extras.

Retail levers you control

Traditional publishers sometimes secure co‑op placement. Front tables, endcaps, newsletters from retailers. That lift helps browse discovery.

For self‑publishing, pull other levers:

• Pricing strategy. Hold ebooks at a market‑aware price. Schedule periodic discounts.
• BookBub Featured Deal. Hard to land, worth the push. Build a review base and a clean product page to improve odds.
• Newsletter swaps with authors in your lane. One clear ask, one clear link.
• KU exclusive or wide. KU increases page reads in Amazon’s ecosystem. Wide increases reach to Kobo, Apple Books, Google Play, and libraries. Choose based on genre norms and your goals. Review choice per release.

Ads without waste

Start small. Test before scaling.

Core options:

• Amazon Ads for keyword search and product targeting. Focus on author names and comp titles first.
• Facebook and Instagram for audience interest and lookalikes. Send clicks to a free prequel for list growth, or to a discounted book one.
• BookBub CPC for author followers and category targets.

Track three numbers:

• ROAS, revenue divided by ad spend.
• Conversion rate on product pages.
• Read‑through across a series. Example, if book one buyers produce 12 dollars in total series revenue on average, spending up to 6 dollars to win a new reader can make sense.

Pause what bleeds money. Redirect budget to winners. Rinse and refine weekly.

Launch vs backlist, two different jobs

Plan a 90‑day sprint for launch:

• Cover reveal and preorders.
• ARC wave and early reviews.
• Price promo during week one, plus two ad channels.
• Three to five podcast or blog features if you are trad, or a guest post and newsletter swaps if you are self‑publishing.

Then shift to the long game:

• Quarterly price promos on older titles.
• Fresh ads for book one when a new release lands.
• Box sets and omnibus editions for a series.
• Audio, large print, or hardcover when demand supports new formats.

Backlist pays rent. Treat older books like assets, not leftovers.

Your one‑page plan and media kit

One page keeps focus sharp.

Include:

• Audience. Who they are, where they hang out, what they love.
• Hooks and comps. Two hooks, three comparison titles or authors.
• Goals and budget. Units, revenue, and money set aside for promos and ads.
• Timeline. Milestones from ARC to 90 days post‑launch.
• KPIs. Email list growth, preorders, review count, ROAS.

Media kit bundle:

• Short bio and author photo.
• Cover in high and low res.
• Blurb, tagline, and a 150‑word synopsis.
• Links to retailer pages and website.
• Contact info. Make this easy to find.

Save as a folder with clear filenames. Share via a single link.

A reviews pipeline that runs itself

Build once, then repeat for each release.

Steps:

• Recruit 30 to 100 ARC readers through your newsletter and back matter sign‑ups.
• Collect blurbs from two to four authors in your niche. Send a tight ask with a two‑week window.
• Schedule emails, ARC send date at T‑30, reminder at T‑14, launch day link, follow‑up at T+7.
• Add a line in your welcome sequence asking new subscribers to request an ARC for the next book.

Small, consistent systems win. Marketing works best when baked into your writing year, not bolted on at the end. Keep going, learn fast, and stay reader focused.

Choosing Your Path (Plus Hybrid Options and Red Flags)

You want a clear answer. There is no single right path. There is your book, your goals, and your appetite for the work beyond the words. Decide with eyes open, then move.

Start with the book

Some genres reward speed, series momentum, and direct reader connection.

• Romance series, fantasy with rapid release, thrillers geared to binge reading. Indie suits these. Readers devour, platforms reward volume, margins stay healthy.
• Literary fiction, children’s picture books, illustrated non‑fiction. Traditional suits these. Production is specialized, bookstore reach matters, reviews in trade outlets drive attention.

Look at your comps. Where did those authors find success. If most are indie, weigh indie first. If award lists and bookstore tables dominate, weigh traditional.

Mini‑exercise:

• List three comps by author and format.
• Note their path, indie or traditional.
• Circle the path your audience expects.

Define your career goals

Pick two priorities.

• Bookstore presence and library reach.
• Speed to shelf.
• Upfront money.
• Full creative control.
• Long tail revenue.
• Support for foreign or audio rights.

Traditional favors bookstore reach, award submissions, and foreign rights scouting. Indie favors speed, control, and higher per‑copy margins. Either path supports a long career, provided you commit.

Write your two non‑negotiables on a sticky note. Keep it on your desk.

Time and temperament check

Indie rewards a builder’s mindset. You plan releases, test covers, watch dashboards, and iterate. You will project manage freelancers. You will study ads enough to avoid waste.

Traditional suits writers who want to focus on the manuscript and collaborate with a house. You still promote, you still show up, but a team runs production and sales.

Quick self‑quiz. Give each statement a yes or no.

• I enjoy spreadsheets.
• I like making decisions fast and learning from results.
• I will email strangers about partnerships without fear.
• I want to write and hand off the rest to trusted pros.
• I have patience for long timelines.
• I want direct control over pricing and metadata.

Three or more yes answers in the first three items points to indie. More yes in the last three points to traditional or a small press.

Hybrid paths that keep options open

Mix and match by project.

• Self‑publish a series to build a reader base. Pitch a standout standalone to agents.
• Keep ebooks and print indie. License audio to a specialist publisher.
• Work with a reputable small press for niche non‑fiction. Self‑publish your related workbook.
• Run a Kickstarter for a special edition. Keep regular editions on retailers.
• License foreign rights through an agent or rights fair while keeping home territory indie.

Reassess per book. Every project serves a larger plan, or it drains it.

Submission path, if you pursue traditional

Treat submission like a campaign.

• Build a clean query letter with a sharp hook, short bio, and comps.
• Write a one‑page synopsis. Include the ending.
• Prepare sample chapters or a full manuscript, per genre norms.
• Research agents through wish lists, client lists, and interviews. Track why each is a fit.
• Create a simple tracker, name, agency, date sent, response, notes.
• For small presses open to writers, follow guidelines with care and track exclusivity windows.

Expect months, not weeks. Keep writing the next book while you wait.

Red flags to avoid

Predators thrive on eagerness. Slow down when you see:

• “Traditional” publishers asking you to pay for publication or marketing.
• Agents charging reading fees.
• Contracts with no clear reversion trigger. Look for sales thresholds and time limits that return rights.
• “Life of copyright” clauses paired with minimal consideration.
• Non‑compete language so broad it locks you out of your own genre.
• Options that demand first look on unrelated work.
• Royalty statements without audit rights.
• No transparency on print runs, discounts, or returns.

When in doubt, step back. Ask a publishing attorney or an authors’ advocacy group to review.

Build a decision matrix

Make this simple. Five columns across a page.

• Control
• Speed
• Cost
• Risk
• Reach

Score each path 1 to 5 for your current project. Higher is better for your goal. Add notes under each number.

Example, a fast‑release fantasy with three books outlined:

• Indie, Control 5, Speed 5, Cost 3, Risk 3, Reach 3.
• Traditional, Control 2, Speed 2, Cost 5, Risk 2, Reach 4.

Example, a picture book with watercolor art:

• Indie, Control 4, Speed 4, Cost 2, Risk 3, Reach 2.
• Traditional, Control 2, Speed 2, Cost 5, Risk 3, Reach 5.

Scores do not decide for you. They surface tradeoffs so you decide with clarity.

Mini‑exercise:

• Fill the matrix.
• Circle the two columns that matter most for this project.
• Choose the path that wins those two columns.

Talk to writers who live the path

Reach out to three to five authors in your lane on each side. Ask specific questions.

• What surprised you about the timeline.
• How many hours per week go to marketing during launch, and three months later.
• Where does most revenue originate, format and retailer.
• What support did you receive from your team.
• One mistake you will never repeat.
• One thing you would do the same way again.

Offer to trade a quick blurb or a newsletter mention as a thank‑you. Keep the call to 20 minutes. Take notes.

Make a choice, for this book

You are not marrying a model. You are selecting a tool for one project. Pick the path that serves the book in front of you, then execute with intent. If the next book asks for a different path, switch. The only wrong choice is drifting.

Give yourself a deadline to decide. Put it on the calendar. Then get back to the page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Download FREE ebook

Claim your free eBook today and join over 25,000 writers who have read and benefited from this ebook.

'It is probably one of the best books on writing I've read so far.' Miz Bent

Leave this empty

Get free book