How To Create Complex, Believable Characters

Gary Smailes | 7 November 2025

What Makes a Character Complex?

Complexity is not a pile of quirks. It is coherence under pressure. Your reader meets a person with aims, pride, blind spots, and a few surprises. Then you press. They bend, they resist, they reveal. That is where depth lives.

Goals, strengths, flaws, contradictions

Start with a visible goal. Win the scholarship. Close the case. Keep a family together. Pick one thing with a finish line.

Show strengths on the page. She reads people fast. He never misses a deadline. They know how to fix an engine with two tools and a prayer.

Now give a flaw that costs them. Not a cute habit, a real liability. Pride that blocks apologies. Jealousy that poisons trust. Conflict avoidance that lets small fires grow.

Layer a contradiction, public versus private. On stage, he is a fearless comic. In quiet rooms, he rehearses hello three times before speaking. In court, she is steel. At home, she sleeps with a nightlight and a bat by the door. Contradictions invite curiosity, and they guide choices when pressure climbs.

Mini exercise:

• Write your character’s goal in one sentence with a verb and a deadline.
• List two strengths that help, then one flaw that hurts.
• Add one public trait and one private reversal.

Want versus need

The external want drives plot. It moves feet. A trophy, a cure, a promotion.

The internal need powers the arc. It changes the heart. Acceptance, humility, courage, forgiveness.

Tension rises when want and need collide. A reporter wants the scoop. She needs to learn restraint. Give her a source who trusts her with a story that will harm a child if published today. The scene writes itself.

Quick test:

• If the want disappears, does the book still move forward. If not, good.
• If the need resolves early, does the person feel flat. If yes, move the key insight later.

Misbelief and the truth that breaks it

A misbelief is a private rule. Love equals weakness. Winning equals worth. Authority equals safety. It feels logical from their point of view, given their past.

You will throw truth at that rule. Not through speeches. Through outcomes. They cling to the rule. They pay for it. They loosen their grip. Or they double down and fall.

Three-beat method:

• Seed the rule early with a small choice, no fanfare.
• Break the rule once and reward them, so the new way tempts.
• Break the rule again when stakes peak, and pay it off with transformation or loss.

Example:

• Misbelief, asking for help invites harm.
• Truth, trust chosen well brings strength.
• Beat one, she declines help, loses a lead.
• Beat two, she risks a small ask, gains a clue.
• Beat three, she asks big at the climax, team shows up, win lands with a cost.

Stakes tied to values

Pain only works when it hits values. What do they defend without thinking. Family reputation. Freedom of movement. Professional pride. A handmade garden planted with a late mother.

Tie loss to those values. Fire the character and watch them shrug. Threaten their license after years of sacrifice, watch them sweat. End a friendship over a moral line, and that will sting.

Keep it personal:

• Name a value in one word.
• Write the worst-case loss connected to that value.
• Place a smaller version of that loss in act one, then a sharper version at the dark moment.

Start with an archetype, then subvert

Archetypes help you orient. Mentor. Trickster. Caregiver. Lover. Warrior. They give you a starting pose.

Then add lived detail until the pose drops. A mentor with dyslexia who memorizes entire briefs through audio and walks clients through cases with patience born from that struggle. A caregiver who runs a black-market supply chain on the side because care costs money and red tape kills. A trickster who refuses to lie to children, ever, even when the truth will end a party.

Use specificity from work, region, faith, slang, hobbies, and past jobs. Give them one uncommon skill and one mundane worry. The combo feels human.

Exercise:

• Pick an archetype.
• List three default traits for it.
• Write three counters pulled from life.
• Draft a two-line intro where both signals appear.

Action step: the Character Compass

One page. No prose, only bullets. Tape it above your desk. Update as you draft.

• Want. External, concrete, time-bound. Example, win the grant this quarter.
• Need. Internal growth in one phrase. Example, learn to share credit.
• Misbelief. The false rule from backstory. Example, praise makes you soft.
• Fear. The nightmare you poke during plot turns. Example, public humiliation.
• Core value. The hill they defend. Example, work done right.
• Breaking point. The line they will not cross, or the moment they will, with fallout. Example, betraying a friend to save a career.

Finish with two lines:

• If they get the want without the need, they end like this.
• If they embrace the need, the final image looks like this.

Now write with the compass in sight. When a scene stalls, check whether the choice on the page hits one of those lines. If not, tweak the setup until the decision hurts for a reason.

Complexity arrives when goals meet pressure, when a lie meets proof, when values cost something. Build from those anchors. Your reader will feel a pulse instead of a profile.

Build Psychology and Backstory With Purpose

Backstory gives you reasons, not excuses. You are building the engine under the hood. The reader will feel the torque when pressure hits.

Three formative moments

Pick three beats that still echo. One wound, one triumph, one betrayal. Name the age, the event, and the rule learned.

Example character, Mina, municipal lawyer.

• Wound, 12. Her complaint about a teacher got her mother fired from the same school. Rule learned, speak up and someone pays.
• Triumph, 19. Won tuition through a debate scholarship. Rule learned, win or sink.
• Betrayal, 27. Mentor presented her memo as his work. Rule learned, trust equals risk.

Now connect each to a coping move used today.

• From the wound, she hoards information, avoids sharing drafts.
• From the triumph, she overprepares, outworks everyone, sleeps in her office.
• From the betrayal, she keeps relationships cordial, never intimate.

You have seeds for choices, not paragraphs of history. When a scene turns, pick a move from this list and show it in action.

Mini exercise:

• List your three moments in one line each.
• Write the rule learned in five words.
• Write one coping move that springs from the rule.

Triggers and stress patterns

Labels sit still. People move. Map sparks that set your character off, then chart how behavior tilts under strain.

Start with three hot buttons:

• Anger spark, someone talks over them.
• Shame spark, public correction.
• Protectiveness spark, a younger worker gets blamed.

Now, show the pattern. Mina when calm, asks questions and gathers facts. Mina under pressure, speaks faster, interrupts, clamps down on help. She goes terse in text threads. She triple checks email before sending, then sends late.

You have tells for dialogue, pacing, and the body. Use repetition on purpose. Let a friend call it out by chapter five. Growth shows when the pattern shifts.

Quick test:

• Write one scene beat where a spark appears.
• Show a small slip in control.
• Add a cost, a missed call, a delay, a frayed bond.

Backstory on a diet

Write plenty for yourself. Keep the plate clean for the reader. Most history belongs under behavior, voice, and choice.

Do this:

• Freewrite two pages about the wound. No filters.
• Underline three details you love.
• Transfer one detail into a scene through action or subtext.

Example, instead of a paragraph about her mentor, have Mina refuse a lunch invite from a senior partner. She checks the door lock twice after he leaves. The scene breathes without a flashback. Later, place a single, sharp line of context during an argument. He took my work once. No more.

Dialogue earns backstory. People rarely deliver monologues about childhood. They drop hints under stress. They deflect. They joke. They change the subject.

Grounded research

Profession, culture, community, place, belief. Get them right. You owe your reader clarity and you owe real people respect.

Talk to workers in the field. Read forums, trade publications, schedules. Visit a setting if possible. Learn the slang people use when no one records them. Note what bores them. Note what delights them. The mundane details carry weight.

For identity and culture beyond your own, bring in sensitivity readers. Pay them. Ask specific questions. Where did you flinch. Where did I flatten. What felt true. Then fix the work. Thank them on the acknowledgments page.

Frameworks as prompts

Personality frameworks help with patterns. Use them as idea mines, not cages. Enneagram points you toward a fear core. Big Five points you toward social energy, order, openness. Pick a type, pull two behaviors, then forget the label while drafting.

Example, an Enneagram Three often fears worthlessness. Translate to text, your character overstates wins, hides struggle, and keeps a highlight reel on loop. In a scene, a partner asks for help. Your character smiles, says fine, then drowns in silence. You did not write a trait list. You wrote a choice with fallout.

If a beat feels forced because a chart said so, cut the chart. Follow the person on the page.

Action step, the contradiction grid

Contradictions make people feel real. Build them on purpose. Two columns. Five lines.

Left column, I am. Right column, Except when.

Examples:

• I am patient. Except when someone lies to me.
• I am generous. Except when my time gets wasted.
• I am brave. Except when praise starts piling up.
• I am loyal. Except when my code gets crossed.
• I am tidy. Except when grief hits.

Now mine for beats.

• Set up the left-hand trait in act one. Pay off the right-hand break under stress.
• Pair the break with a cost, a conflict, or a reveal.
• Use variation to show growth. By the end, one break softens. Or hardens, if you write a fall.

Short drill:

• Take your top I am line.
• Write a two-sentence moment that proves it.
• Throw in the Except when trigger.
• Write the crack, one gesture, one line of dialogue, one choice.

The goal is pressure-tested behavior. Not pathology. Not a catalog. You want a person whose history leaves marks, whose patterns shift under fire, whose choices make sense before they surprise. When the past and the present argue inside one scene, readers lean in. They trust you. They follow.

Goals, Conflict, and the Character Arc

Characters move because they want something. They grow because they need something else. Give both. Make both costly.

External goal vs internal need

External goal lives on the surface. Measurable. Visible. Deadline attached. A number helps. A date helps more.

Internal need lives under the skin. A belief or habit which must change. Growth will demand risk, pride, money, safety, status, or love. No fee, no arc.

Example, Mina, a municipal lawyer.

• External goal, secure an injunction by Friday to stop a mass eviction.
• Internal need, learn to trust partners and ask for help, which risks pride and control.

Write your own pair.

• Want, a sentence with a number and a deadline. Win three new clients by June. Finish the grant before Monday midnight. Fix the farm’s irrigation within two days.
• Need, a sentence with a verb that suggests change. Admit fear. Set a boundary. Tell the truth. Forgive a rival.

If the need costs nothing, raise the price.

Conflict from values, not fog

Indecision bores. Values in collision spark drama. Build tension from two good options which cannot both win. Loyalty against freedom. Honesty against safety. Mercy against fairness. Romantic love against self-respect.

Force a trade. Let Mina face this, expose a colleague’s fraud to save tenants, or keep silent to protect a friend. No silent treatment from the author. Put the choice on the page. Then charge a price either way.

Quick drill.

• Pick two values your character honors.
• Write one scene beat where both align.
• Write a second beat where they collide.
• Name the cost for each fork.

Choose an arc type

Pick a path, then plot the steps. Three broad options.

• Positive arc. Character embraces a harder truth. Old lie weakens. Relationships deepen.
• Flat arc. Character holds a hard-won truth. Pressure spreads outward. Others shift around this center.
• Negative arc. Character rejects truth, or learns the wrong one. Competence rises while soul drains, or the reverse.

Tie the choice to your premise. A comedy often suits a positive or flat arc. A tragedy often follows a negative arc. Any genre welcomes any path with enough honesty.

Map key beats

Use a beat tool. Story Circle. 7-Point. Save the Cat. Pick one and stick with it for a draft. Then check these anchors.

For Mina, a positive arc map:

• Opening state. Competent, closed-off, no help allowed.
• Inciting incident. A developer posts mass notices across a complex.
• First plot turn. Decision to file for an emergency injunction by Friday.
• First pinch. Tenants miss a filing step. Mina refuses volunteer help, workload spikes.
• Midpoint mirror. First ask for help. A junior catches a flaw which would have sunk the case. Control cracks, relief leaks in.
• Second pinch. Mentor pressures Mina to drop the case. Old wound throbs.
• Dark moment. Temporary order denied. Tenants lose faith. Mina believes the old lie again, trust equals risk.
• Climax. Mina exposes the mentor’s memo in court, risks career, doubles down on partnership.
• Resolution. Permanent injunction granted. Mina delegates a follow-up clinic. Guard lowers one notch, not to zero.

For a flat arc, adjust.

• Opening truth voiced early.
• Tests spread, community shifts around that stance.
• Climax shows the truth at full pressure.

For a negative arc, twist.

• Midpoint win feeds the lie.
• Dark moment births a harder version of the lie.
• Climax delivers victory with a moral loss, or a final collapse.

Build a scene engine

Every scene needs four parts.

• A goal.
• An obstacle.
• A high-stakes choice.
• A consequence which shifts the next scene.

Short example, hallway outside a courtroom.

• Goal. Get a tenant to sign a declaration before the hearing.
• Obstacle. The tenant’s brother demands cash first.
• Choice. Pay from personal funds, threaten a subpoena, or reveal a damaging photo as leverage.
• Consequence. Mina threatens. The brother storms off. Next scene starts with a missing signer and a judge who hates delays.

Do not hide the choice. Let the reader feel the squeeze. Show the outcome and change the board.

Quick exercise.

• Take a soft scene from your draft.
• Write one sentence for each of the four parts.
• Increase the cost on the choice.
• Rewrite the exit beat to show a new problem created by that choice.

Decisions over reactions

Characters who decide feel alive. Characters who only react feel dragged. Track the balance with a simple pass.

Try this method.

• Mark every decisive move with a D in the margin. Commitments. Risks. Public stances. Burned bridges.
• Mark every reaction with an R. Startle, recoil, reply, flee, vent.
• Count D and R per chapter. Note the midpoint in your plan. Aim for more D than R by that point.
• If R outnumbers D in late chapters, add choices. Not speeches, moves.

Examples of decisions.

• Tell a secret.
• Refuse a deal and lose money.
• Accept a risk and set a time.
• Walk away from a role.

Reactions still belong. Life hits hard. The ratio tells a story about agency. Raise D as the story tightens, unless a tragedy demands a slide toward surrender. Even then, pick choices which tighten the trap.

A closing nudge

Keep the want concrete. Keep the need costly. Build pressure from values, not fog. Plant the beats where readers expect a turn, then earn surprise through character-specific choices. Scene by scene, choice by consequence, the arc reveals a person worth following.

Voice, POV, and On-Page Characterization

A character’s voice is not an accent or a quirky phrase. Voice is choice. Word choice, sentence shape, and what gets noticed first. If readers covered the name on the page, would they still know who is thinking or speaking? Aim for yes.

Shape a distinct voice

Start with three levers, diction, rhythm, and reference points.

• Diction. Short words vs formal ones. Jargon vs plain speech. Swears, pet names, honorifics.
• Rhythm. Fragments or long lines. Breathless runs or steady pacing. Questions or statements.
• Reference points. Work, hometown, hobby, and family produce the go-to comparisons and examples.

Quick contrasts.

• ER nurse, Short. Concrete. Jargon when under pressure. Example, “Pulse thin. Pupils pinprick. Call for tox.”
• Tenured historian, Layered. Measured. Precise qualifiers. Example, “The record suggests a pattern, although gaps in testimony persist.”
• Sixteen-year-old goalie, Lively. Punchy. Team slang. Example, “Coach benched me. Fine. Next shot goes in, mine.”

Write a paragraph of description from each voice about the same hallway. Keep the facts, change the language. Then ask, who wrote which? If the answer feels obvious, you are close.

A note on comparisons. Keep them tied to lived experience. A carpenter compares measurements and materials. A pianist compares timing and tone. Pick two domains per character and return to them. Repetition builds identity.

Deep POV, take off the filter

Filter words create distance, noticed, saw, heard, felt, realized, thought, wondered. Readers do not need the report of perception. They need the perception.

Before, She noticed the kitchen smelled of bleach.
After, Bleach stung her nose.

Before, He felt angry with his brother.
After, Heat climbed his neck. His grip on the keys went white.

Before, I thought the deal was over.
After, The deal was over. The room knew it before I did.

Anchor sensations to the body and the environment. Then add judgment, not “The man wore a suit,” but “The suit was two sizes too brave for him.” Let the character’s opinion tint description.

Slip in micro-thoughts, the sticky little lines that reveal bias and fear.

• Great, another meeting. Because the last one changed the world.
• Smile, nod, keep the job.

Deep POV works in first person or close third. The test is simple, if a camera could record the line, pull it closer. If the line reflects meaning, shove it into the character’s head and let their spin show.

Dialogue with subtext and status

People rarely say the thing. They ask for water when they want forgiveness. They talk about traffic when they mean, I did not want to come.

Keep three layers in mind.

• Surface text, the words said.
• Subtext, the intent.
• Status, who holds power here, and how it shifts.

A short exchange, parent and adult child after a missed dinner.

• Parent, “You found the place.”
• Child, “Maps exist.”
• Parent, “We ordered already.”
• Child, “I grabbed a burger.”

On the surface, logistics. Underneath, hurt. The parent tries to assert control with the order. The child blocks with a tiny defiance, ate elsewhere. Status slides across the table.

Tips.

• Give each speaker a unique vocabulary and cadence. One loves blunt statements. One prefers questions. One never swears. One swears only with friends.
• Plant taboo topics. Mark the moment someone crosses the line.
• Trim greetings and goodbyes. Enter late, exit early. Let overlaps and interruptions show relationship.

Revise for subtext. Take a literal line, “I’m angry you forgot me,” and hide it inside a practical line, “Your spare key is still under the mat.”

Show through choices and behavior

Readers believe what characters do. Not what they say they value.

On the page, show priorities.

• A CEO who picks up a fallen badge for a temp. Respect runs deep.
• A detective who ignores the crying neighbor to study a footprint. Results over comfort.
• A teacher who checks the broken blind before greeting students. Control before connection.

Show blind spots through omission.

• Who gets named and who gets labeled. “Mr. Alvarez” vs “the cleaning lady.”
• What gets described in detail, and what gets waved away.

Watch how they treat low-status characters. Service workers. Children. Staff. Animals. The smallest interaction speaks loud.

Tells, props, and environment

Tells are repeated clusters that reveal mood or history.

• Gesture cluster. Rubs the scar under the jaw when ashamed. Counts stair steps when anxious. Pinches the bridge of the nose when stalling.
• Possessions. The chipped mug from a dead brother. A sterile desk, no photos. A notebook with receipts tucked in.
• Environment choices. Plants thrive or die. Shoes by the door in rows or a heap. Music on or silence.

Vary them under pressure to show change.

• Early, she straightens pens before every meeting. Late, she arrives and lets the spill sit while she speaks first.
• Early, he avoids the family photo. Late, he moves it to the front shelf.

Do not spam a single tic. Build a small menu per character. Then rotate and evolve.

Action step, build a diction bank

Give each POV character a one-page bank. Use it to draft and to revise.

Sections to fill.

• Word list. Favorite verbs, grab, dodge, gut, mend. Forbidden words, maybe they never say sorry, maybe they never use slang.
• Syntax. Average sentence length. Fragment use. Rhetorical questions, yes or no.
• Swear policy. Which words, with whom, and when.
• Address forms. Mom vs Mother. Sir vs first name.
• Reference points. Two domains they pull from, food, mechanics, fashion, scripture, fieldwork.
• Sensory bias. First notice, temperature, faces, smells, texts.
• Judgments. Quick labels they slap on strangers, try hard, time waster, neat freak.
• Taboo topics. Politics at work, money with friends, performance with partners.
• Filler moves. Stall lines and ticks, “Let me think,” checks watch, cleans glasses.

How to use the bank.

• Draft a scene in neutral voice. Then run a pass per POV. Swap dull verbs for bank verbs. Cut filter words. Add one judgment per paragraph.
• Read dialogue out loud. Check cadence against the bank. Trim anything that sounds like the author.
• Color-code a chapter by speaker. Scan for word reuse. Each voice should repeat itself in its own way, not mirror others.
• Revisit the bank after big plot turns. Update stress tells. Adjust taboos once a line gets crossed.

Voice is earned sentence by sentence. Shape it with intent. Keep the camera inside the character’s skull. Let choices and tells do the heavy lifting. Then polish with the bank until no line sounds like anyone else.

Relationships, Cast Design, and Contrast

Characters sharpen against other people. Who sits across from your protagonist matters. Build a network that presses on weak spots and reveals values under pressure.

Design a character web

Think in roles.

• Allies. Help toward the goal, but with limits or costs.
• Antagonists. Block the goal with logic and pride.
• Foils. Contrast traits in a clear way that sparks friction.
• Mirrors. Share a wound or value, show the road ahead or the road not taken.

Pick a protagonist. Give them a want and a flaw. Then pick four players who corner them from different angles.

Example. Protagonist, an ambitious sous-chef who believes kindness is weakness. Wants a promotion.

• Ally. A dishwasher who covers for her late prep days. His agenda, overtime pay and a favor when he needs a reference.
• Foil. A pastry chef who runs a calm, spotless station. Her agenda, keep standards high, no barked orders.
• Mirror. The head chef who sacrificed family for stars. His agenda, keep the star, pass on his approach, warn her off empathy.
• Antagonist. A health inspector who enforces rules. Their agenda, public safety and proof the restaurant follows codes.

Each one presses on her belief. The ally asks for reciprocity. The foil shows respect without fear. The mirror tempts her to double down. The inspector forces procedures, which slows her and exposes corners she cuts.

Give every side character an agenda

Side characters breathe when they want something specific. Not a vibe. A clear outcome.

Ask two questions for each.

• What do they want from the protagonist.
• What do they want from the scene, even if the protagonist were not there.

Write the want in plain terms.

• The dishwasher wants a raise and a written reference.
• The pastry chef wants quiet and clear timing.
• The inspector wants clean logs and proof of training.

Now throw them into a scene. One kitchen. One surprise inspection. Your protagonist wants to push out the tasting menu on time. The dishwasher stalls the inspector by showing the wrong log. The pastry chef refuses to plate early. The inspector calls for temperature checks. Friction appears without anyone turning evil. Agenda makes it.

Mini exercise.

• List three side characters.
• For each, write one line, “I need X from you, and I need Y from this room.”
• Put them in a five-minute scene. No one leaves until two people win something and one person loses something.

Use foils and mirrors for contrast

A foil is a human highlighter. Their difference makes a trait readable. Orderly with chaotic. Old-school with experimental. Optimist with cynic.

Use them to force choices.

• The meticulous partner demands plans. Your improviser must either plan or lose the partner.
• The devout friend refuses a lie. Your hustler must tell the truth or risk the friendship.

A mirror runs parallel. Same wound, different response.

• Two siblings abandoned by a parent. One hoards money. One spends to feel in control. Their conflict speaks to the same fear.

Place foils and mirrors in key beats. Midpoint. Dark moment. Climax. They should show the cost of both paths.

Humanize your antagonists

Villains with twirly mustaches belong in cartoons. Give your antagonist a coherent goal, a virtue, and a logic that would make sense to their friends.

Build a small profile.

• Goal. What outcome do they want.
• Virtue. What do they do well that a decent person might respect.
• Cost they accept. What harm they are willing to cause and why they think it is worth it.

Example. The health inspector.

• Goal. Safe kitchens across the district.
• Virtue. Prepared. Fair. Knows the code and takes no bribes.
• Cost. Will shut a place on a busy night. Believes one foodborne illness is worse than one lost service.

Now write their entrance. Not, “He swaggered in, hungry for power.” Try, “Clipboard ready. He greeted the host by name. He noted the handwashing sign was blocked by a wine promo.” He is here to do a job. He is correct about some things. That tension helps.

Represent diversity with care

Specific beats generic. Trade labels for lived details.

• Start with research. Job, culture, community. Read, interview, listen. Pay people for their time.
• Choose concrete markers that inform choices. A holiday they observe. A food they avoid. A schedule shaped by childcare. A code of respect at work.
• Share agency. Who makes decisions on the page. Who has interior thoughts. Who gets to be wrong and right.
• Check language. Are you using descriptors equally. Who gets named. Who gets described by hair and skin only.
• Use beta readers from the community when possible. Use sensitivity readers when material touches identity and harm. Fix what they flag.

Revision pass idea. Find a flat side character. Replace a label with a detail tied to action. “Old cashier” becomes “Mrs. Nguyen, who keeps a jar of butterscotch for first-time bus drivers. She short-changes no one and logs every receipt.” Now she has taste, habit, and standards.

Action step, build a chemistry map

Map what each relationship partner wants from the other. Then plan one scene to test the bond.

Create a row for each pair.

• A wants from B.
• B wants from A.
• Point of friction.
• Pressure test scene.
• Win, lose, or draw.

Worked example.

• Sous-chef and dishwasher.
  • She wants speed and silence.
  • He wants a raise and respect in front of others.
  • Friction, she barks orders. He slows when disrespected.
  • Scene, Saturday rush. Inspector on site. A pan hits the floor. She has to choose to thank him publicly or risk losing him mid-service.
  • Outcome, she thanks him by name and backs him with the inspector. He pushes through the rush. Trust nudges up.
• Sous-chef and pastry chef.
  • She wants flexibility.
  • Pastry wants precision.
  • Friction, timing.
  • Scene, a VIP arrives early. She asks for a plate ahead. Pastry says no. She can respect the standard or bully the plate out and watch it fail.
• Sous-chef and inspector.
  • She wants speed.
  • Inspector wants compliance.
  • Friction, shortcuts.
  • Scene, he finds unlabeled containers. She can argue or fix. The choice reveals growth or stubbornness.

Keep the map visible as you draft. When scenes stall, pick a pair and run the pressure test. Change the relationship score after each clash. A plus one for trust. A minus one for betrayal. Let the total affect future choices.

Cast design is story design. Give everyone a motive. Set them at angles. Then stand back and watch your protagonist sweat, learn, and choose.

Revision Checklists and Diagnostics

You drafted the book. Now prove the characters hold under pressure. Revision is not guesswork. Treat it like a field test with tools, numbers, and honest questions.

Build a character bible

Keep the facts where you can see them. No more, “Wait, does she hate dogs or own two labs.”

What to include:

• Timeline. Birth year, key moves, job changes, breakups, promotions, the date of the wound.
• Backstory facts. Three formative moments and the belief each planted.
• Voice notes. Diction, pet phrases, metaphors they reach for, taboo words.
• Wardrobe and props. What they wear to blend in, what they wear to fight, what they never leave behind.
• Relationship arcs. How each bond starts, bends, breaks, or heals across the story.
• Off-page history. Old debts, mentors, rivalries, the club they quit, the nickname they hate.

Fast template, one page per character:

• Logline. “Rae, 34, paramedic, believes need makes you weak.”
• Want. “Train for flight medic job.”
• Need. “Accept help or burn out.”
• Misbelief source. “Mother’s relapse at 12.”
• Core value. “Competence.”
• Fear. “Dependence.”
• Breaking point. “Partner injured on a call because Rae refused backup.”
• Tells. “Checks watch during small talk. Folds sleeves before hard news.”
• Relationships. “Partner Luis plus two, sister Eden minus one, captain neutral.”
• Keeps. “Coffee thermos, chipped, from her first save.”

Update this as you revise. When you change a fact, fix it here first.

Run motivation and causality passes

Two questions for every major beat.

• Can you trace the action to want or need.
• Does a choice cause the next plot turn.

Method:

• Print your scene list.
• Next to each scene, write W for want, N for need, or both.
• Mark the moment of decision. Put a star on the line in the scene where the character makes it.
• Draw a line to the consequence in the next scene.

If you cannot find a decision, you have a reaction scene. Keep some, trim the rest, or add a decision inside it.

Example, Rae at work.

• Call comes in, mass casualty. She volunteers, W, it helps her resume.
• Triage splits the team. She refuses backup, N denied. Decision star.
• Partner gets hurt. Consequence. Next scene, captain threatens suspension. New decision, admit fault or double down.

You want a visible chain. This, so that, then this. If you spot a jump cut with no cause, write the missing beat, or change the earlier choice.

Mini exercise:

• Pick three turning points.
• For each, complete this line, “Because my protagonist chose X, the next event Y was possible.”
• If you write “Because fate,” fix the scene.

Heat-map scenes by goal dominance

Who owns the scene. Color, symbol, or letter, your choice.

Steps:

• Assign a marker to the protagonist, one to the main opposition, and one to a key ally.
• Tag each scene with the marker of the character whose goal drives the conflict.
• Count tags by act.

Quick check:

• Opening, the world pushes the protagonist around. Some opposition tags are fine.
• Midpoint and beyond, the protagonist should drive more turns than they absorb.
• Climax, the protagonist dominates. They set the final risk.

If the opposition owns the book, revisit choices. Add moments where your lead flips a loss into a move. Give them initiative that costs them something.

Balance fascination and empathy

You want readers to admire and care. You get there with three levers.

• Competence. Show hard skill on the page. Not a boast. A scene. The surgeon keeps a rhythm during a tricky repair. The thief clocks the pattern on the cameras in one walk-through.
• Vulnerability. Show where they bruise. A panic tell before a speech. A hand that shakes when a song plays. Private, not performative.
• Kindness in action. One choice that helps someone with no payoff. Return a lost phone. Carry groceries upstairs. Sit with a scared kid.

Place a “save the cat” moment early, then echo it under pressure later with higher cost. If your character is too flawless, add a miss. If they read like a puddle, give them a scene where the room turns to them for help.

Audit questions:

• Where is the last time your lead surprised you with competence.
• When do they ask for help, or refuse it, and why.
• Who benefits from their small kindness, and how does that ripple.

Measure what matters

Metrics reveal blind spots. Keep them simple.

• Decisions per act. Count decisive moves made by the protagonist. Target a steady rise. By the midpoint, more decisions than reactions.
• Scene outcome change rate. For each scene, mark if the situation ends better, worse, or sideways. Aim for change two scenes out of three.
• Lines of backstory per chapter. Pick a cap, for example three sentences. If you break the cap, trade those lines for action or subtext.
• Unique word-bank usage in dialogue. Build a diction bank for each POV and a few key side characters. During a pass, tick when a line uses their specific vocabulary. If another character uses their words, check if a status shift or mimicry is in play. If not, revise.

Mini tally sheet:

• Act One. Decisions, 5. Outcome change, 9 of 12. Backstory lines per chapter, under 3.
• Act Two. Decisions, 9. Outcome change, 14 of 18. Backstory lines per chapter, 2 to 4, trim chapter 16.
• Act Three. Decisions, 7. Outcome change, 8 of 9. Diction drift, fix Luis in chapters 22 and 23.

Action step, targeted beta reads and, if needed, a dev edit

Do not hand readers a blank form. Ask sharp questions that point to the spine of the arc.

Send a short survey:

• Motivation. At three scenes you name, what did you think the protagonist wanted. Write it in one sentence.
• Believability under stress. Where did a choice feel off. Mark the line.
• Empathy. When did you care more. When did you care less. Why.
• Growth. Describe the change you saw from first act to last.
• Antagonist. What do they want. Where are they right.
• Dialogue. Which two characters sounded the most alike. Where did voice sing.
• Confusion. List any moment you reread.
• Favorite beat. One scene you would not cut.

Ask for marginal notes on places they stopped reading. Thank them. Pay in trade reads or cash when you can.

If feedback clusters around the same weak joints, bring in a developmental editor. Ask for a read focused on character logic and arc beats. You want notes on motivation, choice chains, and relationship turns. A good editor will ask hard questions, point to scenes to cut or move, and mark dead air. You still own the fixes.

One last pass. Read the book front to back, fast, like a weekend binge. Mark every time your lead makes a decision, pays a price, or changes a tactic. If those three drop for more than two scenes, you have work. Good news, you know exactly where to tune.

Frequently Asked Questions

Download FREE ebook

Claim your free eBook today and join over 25,000 writers who have read and benefited from this ebook.

'It is probably one of the best books on writing I've read so far.' Miz Bent

Leave this empty

Get free book