Developmental Edit Examples – Before and After

You’ve written your novel and it is time to get a professional on board to lift your book to the next level.

This can be an overwhelming process. If you want a deeper insight into the developmental editing process, I suggest you read my essential guide to developmental editing.

Developmental editing is a complex assessment of your book. In over twenty years as a full-time developmental editor, I can safely say that each book and author has brought their own questions.

That said, the process is the same for each story.

In this article, I’ll highlight how a book is edited and then give you three before-and-after case studies so you can see the process in action.

The two-pass system

A developmental editor can use a two-pass system. They read your book twice, develop a hypothesis about where the problems lie, then uncover the evidence they need to lay out the changes that will improve the book.

Here’s the approach I take.

On the first pass, I read the manuscript as a reader. I follow the story and mark the places where my attention drifts, I lose track of what’s happening, or I stop caring about the outcome. My note might be as simple as I’m losing interest here.

On the second pass, I go back to those moments with the whole story in mind. I look for evidence on the page and in the scenes leading up to it. If I felt bored during an interview, I might check when the detective’s reason for asking becomes clear, when the witness tells him something new, and what he does with that information. That gives me enough to suggest a specific revision. I explain the process in more detail in What is developmental editing?

Case studies

Having given you a brief overview of how a book is edited, I want to explore three case studies that show the before and after.

These short examples illustrate the type of feedback you might get. In a full novel, the evidence for a problem can be spread across several scenes, and an editor may ask you to revise more than one passage to solve it.

If you’re considering an edit for your own manuscript, here’s what to expect from a free sample edit.

Here's an outline of the story we will use for the examples...

A detective is trying to catch a serial killer. Last month, he told the mother of a missing woman to give it time. The woman was later found dead. Now Leah has gone missing, and he believes the same man is holding her. He wants to find her alive and bring the killer in.

The three case studies follow consecutive stages of the investigation. First, his partner finds him at the station late at night, reviewing calls for anything that might tell him where Leah is. Next, he interviews a café worker who saw Leah leave with a man and overheard him mention the old bus depot. Finally, the detective and his partner follow the lead to the depot, where she spots movement in an upstairs window.

1. Give the reader a reason to care about the detective

“You’re still here?” his partner asked.

“I’m going back through the calls.”

“Anything new?”

“Nothing yet.”

His partner glanced at the pile of call logs on his desk. “How many have you got left?”

“About half.”

“I’ll leave you to it, then.”

He turned back to the screen.

First pass. I felt indifferent. I could see that the detective was working late, but I had little reason to care what happened to him or whether he found anything.

Second-pass evidence. The detective says he’s “going back through the calls” and has “about half” left. Those lines tell me what he’s doing and how much work remains. They leave out what he hopes to hear, who he’s trying to find, and why he feels he has to keep looking tonight. His partner’s opening question gives him a natural opportunity to show both his goal and his motivation.

Early in the novel, the detective’s partner finds him at his desk after the rest of the team has gone home. The scene is a chance to show how he handles the pressure of a missing-person case. He can hand the work over to the morning shift or keep looking himself.

I’d look back through the earlier scenes for a moment that explains his decision. Last month, another woman went missing. He told her mother to give it time, and the woman was later found dead. His partner already knows the case, so a brief reference to that conversation is enough. I’d also give her a reason to suggest leaving the calls until morning. The detective has been at it for hours, and she can see how tired he is.

After

“You’re still here?” his partner asked.

“I’m looking for the call that tells us where he’s holding Leah.”

“You’ve been staring at that screen since six.” She rested a hand on the back of his chair. “Uniform can go through them in the morning.”

“Last month I told her mother the first girl would turn up. I’m not asking her to wait until morning again.”

His partner took her coat off and laid it over the back of the chair beside him. “Which ones have you listened to?”

He slid the top sheet towards her. “Start where the ticks stop.”

Now I want him to find Leah, and I understand why he can’t walk away. The line about her mother makes his guilt specific. When his partner offers him a chance to go home, his decision to stay tells me something about him.

His partner’s decision matters too. In the first version, she leaves him to get on with it. Here, she hears why he’s staying and sits down to help. The scene ends with two people searching for a particular thing, which gives the reader a way to judge their progress when the investigation picks up again.

2. Give the interview a purpose

“How long have you worked here?” the detective asked.

“Six years. Seven in February.”

“Always on nights?”

“Mostly. I used to do Tuesdays, but now I do Thursdays.”

“Did you ask to change?”

“Yes. Tuesdays were getting awkward. My sister used to pick up my son, but she’s got a new job now.”

“And Thursdays are easier?”

“Most weeks.”

“Is it usually this quiet?”

“Depends on the weather. We get more people in when it rains.”

“Were you working last Thursday?”

“Yes. I was here until closing.”

“What time did you close?”

“Ten. A little after, maybe. I still had the coffee machine to clean.”

“Were you here on your own by then?”

“Yes, the other woman usually leaves at eight.”

“Did anything unusual happen?”

“Nothing I can think of.”

First pass. I was bored. By the time the detective got to last Thursday, I was already skimming for the part that mattered.

Second-pass evidence. Most of the exchange is about the witness’s shift pattern, her childcare arrangements and how busy the café gets when it rains. The detective never asks about Leah, and the last answer, “Nothing I can think of,” leaves him without a lead. I’d start where he asks about Leah and end as soon as he has a lead he can follow.

The detective has traced Leah’s movements to a café where she stopped the night she disappeared. He’s speaking to the woman who worked behind the counter. She saw Leah leave and overheard something that could give him his first lead. At this point in the book, the reader has already watched him follow up several calls that went nowhere.

The question about anything unusual is part of the problem. It asks the witness to decide what counts as unusual. From her side of the counter, a customer leaving with a man might have looked ordinary. Once the detective asks whether Leah was alone, she has a specific moment to recall. Hearing that Leah left with someone then gives him a reason to ask what the witness heard.

After

“You said Leah came in last Thursday. Was she alone?”

“When she came in, yes. But she left with a man.”

“Did you hear what they said?”

“He told her to wait in the car. He said he just needed to pick something up from the old bus depot.”

The first answer gives the detective a reason to ask the next question. The second sends him to the depot. I’m curious about what he’ll find there, and the next scene can take me straight to it.

I’d keep the opening question specific even if the author wanted a longer interview. The witness might hesitate over which night it was, or remember the man only after the detective shows her a photograph of Leah. Either beat would matter if it affected how much confidence he could put in the lead. Here he has enough to decide where to go, and the reader has a question to carry into the next scene. What was the man doing at a depot that was supposed to be closed?

3. Show where the detectives are and who’s speaking

They walked along the street.

“That’s it up ahead.”

“I thought it was closed.”

“Look at the upstairs window.”

“You think someone’s still in there?”

“Someone was a second ago.”

“How long have you been looking?”

“Since we got here.”

They kept walking.

“Can you still see them?”

“No.”

First pass. I was confused. I had to reread the exchange to work out who’d seen someone move, and I was still unsure where the detectives were standing in relation to the depot.

Second-pass evidence. “They walked along the street” gives me no position I can picture in relation to the depot. “That’s it up ahead” could come from either officer, and the later lines have no dialogue tags or actions to tell me who saw the movement. I’d use a few details from the walk to place the officers and attach the important lines to the person saying them.

The lead brings the detective and his partner to the old bus depot after dark. His partner spots movement in an upstairs window as they walk towards it. The scene should leave the reader wondering who’s inside and whether the two officers have been seen. For that to work, the reader needs to be able to picture the walk and know which officer caught the movement.

I’d start by deciding what each officer can see. They’re on the opposite pavement, with a clear view of the upper windows. His partner is already looking up when she slows at the bus stop. The detective is checking the gates, so he turns towards the window a beat too late. That difference explains why she’s sure someone was there and he has to take her word for it.

After

They walked down the pavement opposite the depot, past a row of shuttered shops. His partner slowed at the bus stop.

“That’s it up ahead,” she said.

The detective looked across the street. A chain hung through the depot gates. “I thought it was closed.”

“Look at the upstairs window.”

He looked up. The room behind the glass was dark. “You think someone’s still in there?”

“Someone was a second ago.” His partner kept walking. “I saw them move away from the glass.”

The detective tried to catch the same angle as he passed the bus shelter. From farther down the pavement, the frame hid half the window.

“Can you still see them?” he asked.

His partner glanced once more across the road. “No.”

I know the officers are across the street, that the gates are chained, and that his partner saw someone upstairs. Now I feel uneasy. If she could see someone in the window, could they see her too?

The placement of the dialogue does some of that work. The detective’s look at the gates sits beside his remark that he thought the depot was closed. His partner’s movement sits beside her account of what she saw. Once those lines are anchored, a short instruction like “Look at the upstairs window” is easy to place by following the exchange. I can stay with the officers as they move past the shelter and wonder whether the figure has left the room or is still watching from farther back.